 










              Tools and Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction
              Processing Applications


              By William Z. Zahavi, Frances A. Habib, and Kenneth J. Omahen



          Abstract                               to the success or failure
              Sizing transaction                 of a business, based on the
             processing systems                  level of performance the
             correctly is a difficult            application provides. In
             task. By nature,                    transaction processing,
             transaction processing              poor application
             applications are not                performance can translate
             predefined and can vary             directly into lost
             from the simple to the              revenues.

             complex. Sizing during               The risk of implementing
             the analysis and design             a transaction processing
             stages of the application           application that performs
             development cycle is                poorly can be minimized
             particularly difficult.             by estimating the proper
             It is impossible to measure         system size in the early
             the resource requirements           stages of application
             of an application which is          development. Sizing
             not yet written or fully            estimation includes
             implemented. To make sizing         configuring the correct
             easier and more accurate            processor and proper
             in these stages, a sizing           number of disk drives and
             methodology was developed           controllers, given the
             that uses measurements from         characteristics of the
             systems on which industry-          application.
             standard benchmarks have             The sizing of transaction
             been run and employs                processing systems is a
             standard systems analysis           difficult activity. Unlike
             techniques for acquiring            traditional applications
             sizing information. These           such as mail, transaction
             metrics are then used to            processing applications
             predict future transaction          are not predefined. Each
             resource usage.                     customer's requirement

             Introduction                        is different and can
              The transaction processing         vary from simple to
             marketplace is dominated            complex. Therefore,
             by commercial applications          Digital chose to develop
             that support businesses.            a sizing methodology that
             These applications                  specifically meets the
             contribute substantially            unique requirements of
                                                 transaction processing

                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991  1

 


           Tools and Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



             customers. The goal                  The third principle is that
             of this effort was to               the sizing methodology
             develop sizing tools and            must employ tools and
             techniques that would help          techniques appropriate
             marketing groups and design         to the current stage of
             consultants in recommending         the customer's application
             configurations that meet            design cycle. Early in the
             the needs of Digital's              effort to develop a sizing
             customers. Digital's                methodology, it was found
             methodology evolved over            that a distinction must be
             time, as experience was             made between preliminary
             gained in dealing with              sizing and sizing during
             the real-world problems             later stages of the
             of transaction processing           application development
             system sizing.                      cycle. Preliminary sizing
              The development of                 occurs during the analysis
             Digital's transaction               and design stages of the
             processing sizing                   application development
             methodology was guided              cycle. Therefore, no
             by several principles.              application software exists
             The first principle is              which can be measured.
             that the methodology                Application software does
             should rely heavily upon            exist in later stages of
             measurements of Digital             the application development
             systems running industry-           cycle, and its measurement
             standard transaction                provides valuable input
             processing benchmarks.              for more precise sizing
             These benchmarks provide            activities.

             valuable data that                   For example, if a customer
             quantifies the performance          is in the analysis or
             characteristics of                  design stages of the
             different hardware and              application development
             software configurations.            cycle, it is unlikely that
              The second principle is            estimates can be obtained
             that systems analysis               for such quantities as
             methodologies should be             paging rates or memory
             used to provide a framework         usage. However, if the
             for acquiring sizing                application is fully
             information. In particular,         implemented, then tools
             a multilevel view of a              such as the VAXcluster
             customer's business is              Performance Advisor (VPA)
             adopted. This approach              and the DECcp capacity
             recognizes that a manager's         planning products can be
             view of the business                used for sizing. These
             functions performed by an           tools provide facilities
             organization is different           for measuring and analyzing
             from a computer analyst's           data from a running system
             view of the transaction             and for using the data as
             processing activity. The            input to queuing models.

             sizing methodology should
             accommodate both these
             views.

          2  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991

 


 and   Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



              The term sizing, as used           used to describe the work
             in this paper, refers to            performed by the business.
             preliminary sizing. The             The Sizing Metrics and
             paper presents the metrics          Sizing Formulas sections
             and algebra used in the             describe the algorithms
             sizing process for DECtp            that use platform and
             applications. It also               business metric information
             describes the individual            to perform transaction
             tools developed as part             processing system sizing.
             of Digital's transaction
             processing sizing effort.        Platforms

          Sizing                                  The term platform is used
                                                 in transaction processing
              The purpose of sizing              sizing methodology to
             tools is twofold. First,            encompass general customer
             sizing tools are used to            preferences for the
             select the appropriate              hardware and software
             system components and to            upon which the transaction
             estimate the performance            processing application will
             level of the system in              run.
             terms of device utilization          The hardware platform
             and user response times.            specifies the desired
             Second, sizing tools bridge         topology or processing
             the gap between business            style. For example,
             specialists and computer            processing style includes a
             specialists. This bridge            centralized configuration
             translates the business             and a front-end and back-
             units into functions that           end configuration as
             are performed on the system         valid alternatives. The
             and, ultimately, into               hardware platform may also
             units of work that can be           include specific hardware
             quantified and measured in          components within the
             terms of system resources.          processing style. (In this

              In the sections that               paper, the term processor
             follow, a number of                 refers to the overall
             important elements of               processing unit, which
             the sizing methodology              may be composed of multiple
             are described. The first            CPUs.)
             of these elements is the             The software platform
             platform on which the               identifies the set of
             transaction processing              layered products to be
             system will be implemented.         used by the transaction
             It is assumed that the              processing application,
             customer will supply                with each software product
             general preferences for             identified by its name
             the software and hardware           and version number. In
             configuration as part of            the transaction processing
             the platform information.           environment, a software
             The Levels of Business              platform is composed of
             Metrics section details             the transaction processing
             the multilevel approach             monitor, forms manager,


                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991  3

 


           Tools and Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



             database management system,
             application language, and
             operating system.                   usage requires that a set

              Different combinations             of metrics be defined.
             of software platforms may           These metrics reflect the
             be configured, depending            business activity and the
             on the hardware platform            system load. The business

             used. A centralized                 metrics are the foundation
             configuration contains all          for the development
             the software components             of several transaction
             on the same system. A               processing sizing tools and
             distributed system is               for a consistent algebra
             comprised of a front-end            that connects the business
             processor and a back-               units with the computer
             end processor; different            units.

             software platforms may               The business metrics
             exist on each processor.            are natural forecasting

                                                 units, business functions,
          Levels of Business Metrics             transactions, and
              The term business metrics          the number of I/Os
             refers collectively to the          per transaction. The
             various ways to measure             relationship among these
             the work associated with            levels is shown in Figure
             a customer's business.              1. In general, a business
             In this section, various            may have one or more
             levels of business metrics          natural forecasting units.
             are identified and the              Each natural forecasting
             relationship between                unit may drive one or
             metrics at different                more business functions. A
             levels is described. [1]            business function may have
             As mentioned earlier, the           multiple transactions, and
             levels correspond to the            a single transaction may
             multilevel view of business         be activated by different
             operation typically used            business functions. Every
             for systems analysis. The           transaction issues a
             organization or personnel           variety of I/O operations
             most interested in a metric         to one or more files,
             in relation to its business         which may be physically
             operation is noted in the           located on zero, one, or
             discussion of each metric.          more disks. This section
                                                 discusses the business
              The decomposition of               metrics but does not
             the business application            discuss the physical
             requirements into                   distribution of I/Os
             components that can be              across disks, which is
             counted and quantified              an implementation-specific
             in terms of resource                item.

              A natural forecasting unit         generally uses a volume
             is a macrolevel indicator           indicator to measure
             of business volume. (It is          the level of success
             also called a key volume            of the business. The
             indicator.) A business              volume is often measured

          4  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991

 


 and   Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



             in time intervals that              by a user. Each of the
             reflect the business                interactions mentioned in
             cycle, such as weekly,              the above business function
             monthly, or quarterly.              is a transaction. The
             For example, if business            measurement metric for a
             volume indicators were              transaction is the number
             "number of ticket sales             of transaction occurrences
             per quarter," or "monthly           per business function.
             production of widgets,"             Transactions may be used
             then the corresponding              by low-level managers to
             natural forecasting units           track the activity of their
             would be "ticket sales"             groups.
             and "widgets." Natural               The bulk of commercial
             forecasting units are used          applications involves
             by high-level executives            the maintaining and
             to track the health of the          moving of information.
             overall business.                   This information is data

              Business functions are             that is often stored on
             a logical unit of work              permanent storage devices
             performed on behalf of a            such as rotational disks,
             natural forecasting unit.           solid state disks, or
             For example, within an              tapes. An I/O operation
             airline reservation system,         is the process by which
             a common business function          a transaction accesses
             might be "selling airline           that data. The measurement
             tickets." This business             metric for the I/O profile
             function may consist of             is the number of I/O
             multiple interactions with          operations per transaction.
             the computer (e.g., flight          I/O operations by each
             inquiry, customer credit            transaction are important
             check). The completion              to programmers or system
             of the sale terminates              analysts.
             the business function,               In addition to issuing
             and "airline ticket" acts           I/Os, each transaction
             as a natural forecasting            requires a certain amount
             unit for the enterprise             of CPU time to handle
             selling the tickets. The            forms processing. (Forms
             measurement metric for              processing time is not
             business functions is               illustrated in Figure 1.)
             the number of business              The measurement metric
             function occurrences per            for forms processing time
             hour. Business functions            is the expected number of
             may be used by middle-              fields. The number of input
             level managers to track             and output fields per form
             the activity of their               are important metrics for
             departments.                        users of a transaction

              A transaction is an                processing application or
             atomic unit of work                 programmer/system analysts.
             for an application, and
             transaction response
             time is the primary
             performance measure seen

                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991  5

 


           Tools and Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



              By collecting information          directly into decreased
             about a transaction                 productivity and lost
             processing application              revenues.
             at various levels, high-             When a customer generates a
             level volume indicators             formal Request For Proposal
             are mapped to low-level             (RFP), the performance
             units of I/O activity. This         goals for the transaction
             mapping is fundamental to           processing system typically
             the transaction processing          are specified in detail.
             sizing methodology.                 The specification of goals

              Performance goals play             makes it easier to define
             a particularly important            the performance bounds. For
             role in the sizing of               customers who supply only
             transaction processing              general performance goals,
             systems. [2] The major              it is assumed that the
             categories of performance           performance goal takes the
             goals commonly encountered          form of bounds for device
             in the transaction                  utilizations.
             processing marketplace are           Overall response time
             bounds for                          consists of incremental

             o  Device utilization(s)            contributions by each major
             o  Average response time            component of the overall
                for transactions                 system:

             o  Response time quantiles          o  Front-end processor

                for transactions                 o  Back-end processor

              For example, a customer            o  Communications network
             might specify a required            o  Disk subsystem
             processor utilization of
             less than 70 percent. Such           A main objective in
             a constraint reflects the           this approach to sizing
             fact that system response           was to identify and
             time typically rises                use specific metrics
             dramatically at higher              that could be easily
             processor utilizations.             counted for each major
             A common performance                component. For instance,
             goal for response time              the number of fields per
             is to use a transaction's           form could be a metric
             average response time and           used for sizing front-
             response time quantiles.            end processors because
             For example, the proposed           that number is specific
             system should have an               and easily counted. As
             average response time of            the path of a transaction
             x seconds, with 95 percent          is followed through the
             of all responses completing         overall system, the units
             in less than or equal to            of work appropriate for
             y seconds, where x is               each component become
             less than y. Transaction            clear. These units become
             response times are crucial          the metrics for sizing
             for businesses. Poor                that particular component.
             response times translate            The focus of this paper
                                                 is on processor sizing

          6  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991

 


 and   Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



             with bounds on processor            generated by a transaction
             utilization. Processors             provides a good prediction
             generally constitute                of the required amount
             the major expense in any            of CPU processing. [3]
             proposed system solution.           Numerous industry-standard
             Mistakes in processor               benchmark tests for product
             sizing are very expensive           positioning were run on
             to fix, both in terms of            Digital's processors. These
             customer satisfaction and           processors were configured
             cost.                               as back-end processors in a
             Sizing Metrics                      distributed configuration
                                                 with different software
              Transaction processing             platforms.
             applications permit a large          The base workload for
             number of users to share            this benchmark testing is
             access to a common database         currently the Transaction
             crucial to the business and         Processing Performance
             usually residing on disk            Council's TPC Benchmark
             memory. In an interactive           A (TPC-A, formerly the
             transaction processing              DebitCredit benchmark).
             environment, transactions           [4,5,6] The most complete
             generally involve some              set of benchmark testing
             number of disk I/O                  was run under Digital's VAX
             operations, although the            ACMS transaction processing
             number is relatively small          monitor and VAX Rdb/VMS
             compared to those generated         relational database.
             by batch transaction                Therefore, results from
             processing applications.            this software platform on
             CPU processing also                 all Digital processors were
             is generally small and              used to compute the first
             consists primarily of               sizing metric called the
             overhead for layered                base load factor.
             transaction processing
             software products. Although          The base load factor
             these numbers are small,            is a high-level metric
             they did influence the              that incorporates the
             sizing methodology in               contribution by all layered
             several ways.                       software products on the
              Ratings for relative               back-end processor to the
             processor capacity in a             total CPU time per I/O
             transaction processing              operation. Load factors are
             environment were developed          computed by dividing the
             to reflect the ability of a         total CPU utilization by
             processor to support disk           the number of achieved disk
             I/O activity (as observed           I/O operations per second.
             in benchmark tests).                (The CPU utilization is
             In addition, empirical              normalized in the event
             studies of transaction              that the processor is a
             processing applications             Symmetrical Multiprocessing
             showed that, for purposes           [SMP] system, to ensure
             of preliminary sizing,              that its value falls within
             the number of disk I/Os             the range of 0 to 100
                                                 percent.) The calculation


                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991  7

 


           Tools and Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



             of load factor yields               selected DECtp software
             the total CPU time, in              platform.
             centiseconds (hundredths             To estimate an appropriate
             of seconds), required to            intensity factor for a
             support an application's            nonexistent application,
             single physical I/O                 judgment and experience
             operation.                          with similar applications

              The base load factors              are required. However,
             give the CPU time per               measured cases from a
             I/O required to run the             range of DECtp applications
             base workload, TPC-A, on            shows relatively little
             any Digital processor in            variation in intensity
             a back-end configuration            factors. Guidelines to
             using the ACMS/Rdb. The             help determine intensity
             CPU time per I/O can be             factors are included in the
             estimated for any workload.         documentation for Digital's
             This generalized metric is          internally developed
             called the application load         transaction processing
             factor.                             sizing tools.

              To relate the base load             The work required by any
             factors to workloads                transaction processing
             other than the base,                application is composed of
             an additional metric                two parts: the application
             was defined called the              /database and the forms
             intensity factor. The               management. This division
             metric calculation for              of work corresponds to what
             the intensity factor                occurs in a distributed
             is the application load             configuration, where the
             factor divided by the               forms processing is off-
             base load factor. The               loaded to one or more
             value in using intensity            front-end processors.
             factors is that, once               Load factors and intensity
             estimated (or calculated            factors are metrics that
             for running applications),          were developed to size
             intensity factors can be            the application/database.
             used to characterize any            To estimate the amount
             application in a way that           of CPU time required
             can be applied across all           for forms management, a
             processor types to estimate         forms-specific metric is
             processor requirements.             required. For a first-cut
              Intensity factors vary             approximation, the expected
             based on the software               number of (input) fields is
             platform used. If a                 used as the sizing metric.
             software platform other             This number is obtained
             than a combined VAX ACMS            easily from the business-
             and VAX Rdb/VMS platform            level description of the
             is selected, the estimate           application.

             of the intensity factor             Sizing Formulas
             must be adjusted to
             reflect the resource usage
             characteristics of the

          8  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991

 


 and   Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



              This section describes             time per transaction,
             the underlying algebra              expressed in centiseconds
             developed for processor             per transaction. By
             selection. Different                multiplying this product
             formulas to estimate                by the transactions per
             the CPU time required               second rate, an expression
             for both the application            for processor utilization
             /database and forms                 is derived. Thus processor
             management were developed.          utilization (expressed as a
             These formulas are used             percentage scaled between
             separately for sizing               0 and 100 percent) is the
             back-end and front-end              number of transactions per
             processors in a distributed         second, times the number of
             configuration. The                  I/Os per transaction, times
             individual contributions of         load factor x, times the
             the formulas are combined           intensity factor.
             for sizing a centralized             The performance goal is
             configuration.                      a CPU utilization that is

              The application/database           less than the utilization
             is the work that takes              specified by the customer.
             place on the back-end               Therefore, the calculation
             processor of a distributed          used to derive the load
             configuration. It is a              factor is the utilization
             function of physical disk           percentage provided by the
             accesses. To determine the          customer, divided by the
             minimal CPU time required           number of transactions per
             to handle this load,                second, times the number of
             processor utilization is            I/Os per transaction, times
             used as the performance             the intensity factor.
             goal, setting up an                  Once computed, the load
             inequality that is solved           factor is compared to those
             to obtain a corresponding           values in the base load
             load factor. The resulting          factor table. The base
             load factor is then                 load factor equal to or
             compared to the table               less than the computed
             of base load factors to             value is selected, and its
             obtain a recommendation             corresponding processor
             for a processor type. To            type, x, is returned as the
             reinforce this dependence           minimal processor required
             of load factors on                  to handle this workload.
             processor types, load
             factor x refers to the               The four input parameters
             associated processor                that need to be estimated
             type x in the following             for inclusion in this
             calculations.                       inequality are

              One method for estimating          o  Processor utilization
             the average CPU time per               performance goal
             transaction is to multiply             (traditionally set at
             the number of I/Os per                 around 70 percent, but
             transaction by the load                may be set higher for
             factor x and the intensity             Digital's newer, faster
             factor. This yields CPU                processors)

                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991  9

 


           Tools and Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



             o  Target transactions per           where y equals the CPU
                second (which may be             time for forms processing;
                derived from Digital's           a equals the CPU time
                multilevel mapping of            per form per transaction
                business metrics)                instance, depending on
             o  I/Os per transaction             the forms manager used; b
                (estimated from                  equals the CPU time per
                application description          field per transaction
                and database expertise)          instance, depending on
             o  Intensity factor                 the forms manager used; z
                (estimated from                  equals the expected number
                experience with similar          of fields; and c equals the
                applications)                    scaling ratio, depending on
                                                 the processor type.

              Note: Response time                 This equation was developed
             performance goals do not            by feeding the results of
             appear in this formula.             controlled forms testing
             This sizing formula deals           into a linear regression
             strictly with ensuring              model to estimate the
             adequate processor                  CPU cost per form and per
             capacity. However, these            field (i.e., a and b. The
             performance parameters              multiplicative term, c,
             (including the CPU service          is used to eliminate the
             time per transaction)               dependence of factors a and
             are fed into an analytic            b on the hardware platform
             queuing solver embedded             used to run these tests.
             in some of the transaction
             processing sizing tools,            Sizing Tools

             which produces estimates of          Several sizing tools were
             response times.                     constructed by using the

              Forms processing is                above formulas as starting
             the work that occurs                points. These tools differ
             either on the front-end             in the range of required
             processor of a distributed          inputs and outputs, and
             configuration or in a               in the expected technical
             centralized configuration.          sophistication of the user.

             It is not a function of              The first tool developed
             physical disk accesses;             is for quick, first-
             rather, forms processing            approximation processor
             is CPU intensive. To                sizing. Currently embodied
             estimate the CPU time (in           as a DECalc spreadsheet,
             seconds) required for forms         with one screen for
             processing, the following           processor selection and one
             simple linear equation is           for transactions-per-second
             used:                               sensitivity analysis, it

                                                 can handle back-end, front-
                    y = c(a + bz)                end, or centralized sizing.
                                                 The first screen shows
                                                 the range of processors
                                                 required, given the target
                                                 processor utilization,
                                                 target transactions

          10  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991

 


 and   Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



             per second, expected                product characteristics
             number of fields, and               (e.g., processor and
             the possible intensity              disk) and measured DECtp
             factors and number of               applications. The user
             I/Os per transaction.               can search through the
             (Because the estimation             measured cases to find a
             of these last two inputs            similar case, which could
             generally involves the              then be used to provide
             most uncertainty, the               a starting point for
             spreadsheet allows the              estimating key application
             user to input a range               parameters. The built-in
             of values for each.) The            product characteristics
             second screen turns the             shield the user from the
             analysis around, showing            numeric details of the
             the resulting transaction-          sizing algorithms.
             per-second ranges that               A third tool is a spin-
             can be supported by the             off from the second tool.
             processor type selected by          This tool is a standalone
             the user, given the target          analytic queuing solver
             processor utilization,              with a simple textual
             expected number of fields,          interface. The tool
             and possible intensity              is intended for the
             factors and number of I/Os          sophisticated user and
             per transaction.                    assumes that the user

              The basic sizing formula           has completed the level
             addresses issues that               of analysis required to
             deal specifically with              be able to supply the
             capacity but not with               necessary technical input
             performance. To predict             parameters. No automatic
             behavior such as response           table lookups are provided.
             times and queue lengths,            However, for a completely
             modeling techniques that            characterized application,
             employ analytic solvers             this tool gives the
             or simulators are needed.           sophisticated user a
             A second tool embeds an             quick means to obtain
             analytic queuing solver             performance estimates and
             within itself to produce            run sensitivity analyses.
             performance estimates.              The complete DECtp software
             This tool is an automated           platform necessary to run
             system (i.e., a DECtp               the second tool is not
             application) that requests          required for this tool.
             information from the user           Data Collection
             according to the multilevel
             workload characterization            To use the sizing tools
             methodology. This starts            fully, certain data must
             from general business-level         be available, which allows
             information and proceeds            measured workloads to be
             to request successively             used to establish the basic
             more detailed information           metrics. Guidance in sizing
             about the application.              unmeasured transaction
             The tool also contains a            processing applications
             knowledge base of Digital's         is highly dependent on


                         Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991  11

 


           Tools and Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



             developing a knowledge              DECtrace product can be
             base of real-world                  used to track the rate at
             transaction processing              which events occur.
             application descriptions             The methods for determining
             and measurements. The kinds         the logical-to-physical
             of data that need to be             disk I/O ratio per
             stored within the knowledge         transaction remain open for
             base require the data               continuing study. Physical
             collection tools to gather          disk I/O operations
             information consistent with         are issued based on
             the transaction processing          logical commands from the
             sizing algebra.                     application. The find,

              For each transaction type          update, or fetch commands
             and for the aggregate of            from an SQL program
             all the transaction types,          translate into from zero to
             the following information           many thousands of physical
             is necessary to perform             disk I/O operations,
             transaction processing              depending upon where
             system sizing:                      and how data is stored.
             a. CPU time per disk I/O            Characteristics that affect
                                                 this ratio include the
             b. Disk I/O operations per          length of the data tables,
                transaction                      number of index keys, and
             c. Transaction rates                access methods used to
                                                 reach individual data items
             d. Logical-to-physical disk         (i.e, sequential, random).
                I/O ratio                         Few tools currently

              The CPU to I/O ratio               available can provide
             can be derived from                 data on physical I/O
             Digital's existing                  operations for workloads
             instrumentation products,           in the design stage. A
             such as the VAX Software            knowledge base that stores
             Performance Monitor (SPM)           the logical-to-physical
             and VAXcluster Performance          disk I/O activity ratio is
             Advisor (VPA) products.             the best method available
             [7] Both products can               at this time for predicting
             record and store data               that value. The knowledge
             that reflects CPU usage             base in the second sizing
             levels and physical disk            tool is beginning to be
             I/O rates.                          populated with application
              The DECtrace product               descriptions that include
             collects event-driven               this type of information.
             data. It can collect                It is anticipated that,
             resource items from                 as this tool becomes
             layered software products,          widely used in the field,
             including VAX ACMS monitor,         many more application
             the VAX Rdb/VMS and DBMS            descriptions will be
             database systems, and if            stored in the knowledge
             instrumented, from the              base. Pooling individual
             application program itself.         application experiences
             As an event collector, the          into one central repository
                                                 will create a valuable

          12  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991

 


 and   Techniques for Preliminary Sizing of Transaction Processing Applications



                                                 2. K. Omahen, "Practical
                                                    Strategies for
                                                    Configuring Balanced
             source of knowledge that               Transaction Processing
             may be utilized to provide             Systems," IEEE COMPCON
             better information for                 Spring '89 Proceedings
             future sizing exercises.               (1989): 554-559.

                                                 3. W. Zahavi, "A First
                                                    Approximation Sizing
                                                    Technique-The I/O
          Acknowledgments                           Operation as a Metric
              The authors would                     of CPU Power," CMG '90
             like to acknowledge                    Conference Proceedings
             our colleagues in the                  (forthcoming Dececember
             Transaction Processing                 10-14, 1990).

             Systems Performance Group           4. "TPC BENCHMARK A-
             whose efforts led to the               Standard Specification,"
             development of these sizing            Transaction Processing
             tools, either through                  Performance Council
             product characterization,              (November 1989).

             system support, objective           5. "A Measure of
             critique, or actual                    Transaction Processing
             tool development. In                   Power," Datamation,
             particular, we would                   Vol. 31, No. 7 (April 1,
             like to acknowledge the                1985): 112-118.
             contributions made by Jim           6. L. Wright, W. Kohler,
             Bouhana to the development             W. Zahavi, "The
             of the sizing methodology              Digital DebitCredit
             and tools.                             Benchmark: Methodology

                                                    and Results," CMG '89
          References                                Conference Proceedings
                                                    (1989): 84-92.
             1. W. Zahavi, and J.                7. F. Habib, Y. Hsu, K.
                Bouhana, "Business-                 Omahen, "Software
                Level Description of                Measurement Tools for
                Transaction Processing              VAX/VMS Systems," CMG
                Applications," CMG '88              Transactions (Summer
                Proceedings (1988):                 1988): 47-78.
                720-726.












                         Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 1 Winter 1991  13
=============================================================================
Copyright 1991 Digital Equipment Corporation.  Forwarding and copying of this 
article is permitted for personal and educational purposes without fee 
provided that Digital Equipment Corporation's copyright is retained with the 
article and that the content is not modified. This article is not to be 
distributed for commercial advantage. Abstracting with credit of Digital 
Equipment Corporation's authorship is permitted.  All rights reserved.
=============================================================================
