 










              Foreword


              By Mark F. Kempf, Senior Consulting Engineer, FDDI Program
              Technical Director



              In the early 1980s, Digital        more than 10-megabits
             introduced local area               /second to a single
             network (LAN) products              station. The current and
             based on industry-standard,         projected performance of
             10-megabit/second Ethernet          workstations indicated
             technology. These products          that any new generation
             allowed minicomputers,              of LAN suitable for future
             terminal servers, and               Digital products would
             other network devices to            have to offer an order
             be connected with ease              of magnitude increase in
             and offered unprecedented           bandwidth delivered to
             bandwidth. As local                 a single point. It was
             networks grew in size               also clear that it would
             and began to strain                 have to adhere to a widely
             the capabilities of a               accepted industry standard,
             single LAN in the mid               since users had come to
             1980s, Digital introduced           expect the ability to
             products based on the               interconnect equipment from
             extended LAN concept.               many vendors.
             By connecting multiple               After considerable
             LANs with filtering and             analysis, Digital selected
             forwarding bridges, a much          the emerging ANSI FDDI
             larger number of stations           (fiber distributed data
             could be interconnected             interface) 100-megabit
             with greater aggregate              /second token ring standard
             bandwidth.                          as the basis for our next

              A few years after the              generation of LAN products.
             introduction of extended            The standard met our
             LANs, it became apparent            important requirements and
             that once again the                 showed promise of becoming
             capabilities of existing            widely accepted (today, of
             LANs were being strained,           course, it is). However,
             but this time in two                because the standard
             dimensions. Not only was            was incomplete, our
             there need for greater              plans had to accommodate
             bandwidth in the "backbone"         the implementation of
             of the network, but with            specifications that would
             the advent of much faster           not always be known at
             workstations and servers,           convenient times. Further,
             there was need to bring             because FDDI had not yet


                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  1

 


           Foreword



             been implemented, we had            FDDI and preexisting
             to expect to discover               extended LAN products.
             errors in the existing               It is important to remember
             document and to work with           that Digital does not view
             the standards organization          FDDI as a replacement for
             to correct them. The                Ethernet, but rather as
             first group of articles in          its complement. The large
             this issue of the Digital           number of existing Ethernet
             Technical Journal describes         LANs can be connected to
             how we implemented the              FDDI using another element
             standard and some of the            in Digital's initial FDDI
             techniques we applied to            product offering, the
             deal with change as the             DECbridge 500 FDDI/Ethernet
             standard matured.                   bridge. This product allows

              Of course, in                      multiple Ethernets to
             Digital's business, the             be interconnected using
             implementation of a LAN             FDDI as a backbone.
             technology is only a                Ethernet stations can
             means to an end. The                communicate directly with
             LAN technology must                 stations on FDDI as well
             be incorporated into                as with stations on other
             products that provide               Ethernets. The second group
             useful services to our              of articles in this issue
             customers. One important            describes how we developed
             product in Digital's                these FDDI products.
             initial FDDI offering,               During the entire
             the DEC FDDIcontroller              development process, we
             700 workstation adapter,            relied on several design
             meets the need for more             strategies. One emphasized
             bandwidth delivered to              the importance of designing
             a single station. But               the entire system that
             LAN users have come to              comprises the product
             expect more: manageability,         set, not just individual
             interoperability, and               products. Another was the
             a generally radial                  decomposition of problems.
             wiring scheme; and they             Early in the design
             have large existing                 process, we identified
             LAN infrastructures.                functions that appeared
             Therefore, it was essential         to be independent of
             to introduce FDDI with              others. We took into
             a set of products that              account how each component
             addressed all these needs           that implemented these
             as well. Digital's FDDI             functions would be used
             wiring concentrator,                in the various products
             the DECconcentrator 500,            and how the products would
             permits highly reliable,            interact with each other.
             manageable, radial wiring           In our development plans,
             schemes. DECelms (extended          we assumed that once a
             lan management system)              particular independent
             provides network management         component was designed,
             capability for Digital's            implemented, and tested,

                                                 it could be depended on

          2  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991

 


                                                                       Foreword



             to work as expected when            phases. In the first
             other components were added         phase, we concentrated
             around it. Naturally, we            on analysis and simulation
             could not assume that               of the underlying FDDI
             our initial assessment              algorithms specified by
             of independence was                 the standard. We wanted to
             infallible, and we remained         ensure that they actually
             alert for unexpected                described mechanisms that
             interactions.                       would produce a reliable,
              Another related design             high-performance LAN.
             strategy was partitioning           During this phase we also
             to reduce risk. As                  implemented the standard in
             mentioned before, the               silicon and software, and
             FDDI standard was evolving          combined these components
             and subject to change.              to form complete FDDI test
             Therefore, we physically            stations.

             partitioned our design to            Since standards documents,
             closely mirror the separate         like all written
             sections of the standards           documents, are subject
             document. This approach             to interpretation, two
             helped limit to a single            separate teams were given
             component the impact of             the task of implementation
             standards changes.                  and verification. We used
              The final important                the test stations, first in
             design strategy can be              a simulation environment,
             summarized as "analyze              to execute test scripts
             everything you can,                 developed directly from
             simulate what you can't             the standards documents
             analyze, and prototype              to verify standards
             what you can't simulate."           compliance. The scripts
             The work, expense, and              were also used to verify
             recovery time from errors           details specific to our
             increases with each step            implementation and had
             through this progression,           the additional benefit of
             and the advantages are              making regression testing
             obvious. Of course, it is           after incremental changes
             also obvious that this              relatively easy.

             summary is simplistic                In the second phase we
             since it is impossible              concentrated on proving
             to analyze, simulate, and           that significant numbers
             prototype exhaustively.             of FDDI stations, which had
             It is necessary to step             previously been shown to
             into the gray area of               work individually, could
             risk assessment and                 be interconnected to form
             engineering judgment to             large reliable rings. This
             make satisfactory progress.         was the most important
              FDDI LAN technology                application of the heavily
             development and product             instrumented test systems.
             development was done in             Although analysis and
             three coordinated and               simulation can and did
             somewhat overlapping                yield important results
                                                 in this area, the complex

                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  3

 


           Foreword



             interactions between large
             numbers of asynchronous             out simultaneously with
             stations overwhelm both             engineering design.
             analytical techniques and           For instance, Digital
             available computing power.          maintained a significant

              In the third phase, the            presence at the FDDI
             focus was on producing              standards committee to
             products. From a logic              apprise the committee
             design and software                 of various technical
             standpoint, Digital's               problems we found in
             FDDI products are largely           the standard, to offer
             derived from the test               solutions, and to ensure
             systems used in the                 that our implementation
             previous phases. Of                 reflected the intent of the
             course, laboratory test             standard. In addition, the
             capabilities were removed           close working relationships
             and major changes in                fostered between various
             power and packaging were            organizations, especially
             made; but this approach             between development
             significantly reduced               and manufacturing,

             both the opportunity for            resulted in products
             introducing new errors              with a good balance
             and the time to market.             between time to market,
             We were also able to use            function, performance, and
             the capabilities of the             manufacturing cost.

             laboratory versions to help          The articles in this
             verify the correct function         issue of the Digital
             of the products.                    Technical Journal go

              Numerous other activities          into much greater detail
             that contributed to                 on the subjects I have
             the effectiveness and               touched on. I hope you
             timely delivery of the              find them interesting and
             products were carried               informative.


















          4  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991
=============================================================================
Copyright 1991 Digital Equipment Corporation.  Forwarding and copying of this 
article is permitted for personal and educational purposes without fee 
provided that Digital Equipment Corporation's copyright is retained with the 
article and that the content is not modified. This article is not to be 
distributed for commercial advantage. Abstracting with credit of Digital 
Equipment Corporation's authorship is permitted.  All rights reserved.
=============================================================================
