 










              The DECconcentrator 500 Product


              By William J. Tiffany, G. Paul Koning, and James E. Kuenzel



          Abstract                               Interconnect (CI) bus. All
              Digital's decision                 stations were to be dual
             to implement the fiber              attachment stations (DASs)
             distributed data interface          and the interconnections
             (FDDI) physical topology            between the stations were
             with a dual ring of                 to be wired directly,
             trees, as opposed to a              without patch panels or
             dual ring only, resulted            similar structured wiring
             in the development of               schemes.

             the DECconcentrator                  Using this dual ring
             500 product. The dual               topology is feasible for
             ring of trees topology              a small number of stations
             provides high availability,         in a single, tightly
             manageability, and support          controlled room. However,
             for building wiring                 soon the emphasis of FDDI
             standards. The function             shifted primarily to local
             of the concentrator                 area networks (LANs). A
             demanded that the product           LAN consists of many nodes,
             be reliable, provide for            spread over a large area
             remote management and               and with potentially many
             control, and allow a low            individuals able to connect
             cost per connection. The            and disconnect stations.
             use of common FDDI hardware          To accomodate LAN topology
             and software components             requirements, ANSI chose
             developed by Digital helped         to add the concept of
             the product team to meet            concentrators midway
             these goals.                        in the development of

                                                 the FDDI standard.[1]
          Concentrators in the ANSI FDDI         In the simplest case, a
          X3T9.5 Standard                        concentrator is a device
              In the initial stages              that attaches to a dual
             of its development, the             ring (via A and B ports)
             American National Standards         and provides additional
             Institute (ANSI) standard           ports (M ports) to which
             for the fiber distributed           stations can be connected
             data interface (FDDI)               by means of radially wired
             technology was intended             cables. These additional
             for a computer room system          stations can be single
             interconnect, similar               attachment stations (SASs)
             to Digital's Computer               with a single port (S port)
                                                 rather than the pair of

                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  1

 


           The DECconcentrator 500 Product



                                                  Also, concentrators
                                                 continuously perform
             ports required by a DAS.            link error monitoring
             This simple topology was            (LEM). Each active link is
             soon generalized, allowing          monitored for data errors,
             concentrators to be nested          and a link found to have
             to any depth in a dual ring         excessive data errors
             of trees. Concentrators             is disabled. In this way
             may be singly attached              concentrators ensure that
             (by using an S port plus            the ring error rate, and
             M ports rather than A and           therefore the packet loss
             B ports plus M ports), and          rate, remains acceptably
             DASs may be connected to            low.
             concentrators. Figure 1              Given the many choices
             illustrates the basic FDDI          for concentrator
             topologies.                         interconnection allowed

              FDDI concentrators                 by the ANSI standard,
             are more than wiring                it is possible to
             hubs, unlike certain                construct highly complex
             other LAN technologies.             topologies, including
             They also perform two               many that have "bad"
             functions that are key              properties. When a station
             to network integrity. When          is physically plugged in
             a station's connection              and that connection is
             to a concentrator is                operating properly, the
             activated, a multistep              station should be able
             initialization procedure            to communicate with all
             called physical connection          other stations in its own
             management (PCM) takes              network. This property is
             place, using physical layer         often stated as "Physical
             (PHY) signaling. In this            connectivity equals
             procedure, the station and          logical connectivity,"
             the concentrator exchange           or, in other words, "Being
             some topology information,          plugged in implies being
             and a link confidence test          able to communicate."
             is performed to verify that         In bad topologies, this
             the data integrity on the           property does not hold.
             link is acceptable. Once            Such topologies are very
             the PCM initialization is           confusing to network
             complete, the connection            managers and are therefore
             becomes part of the ring.           undesirable.

              The ANSI standard specifies        therefore depends to some
             some topology rules to              extent on the competence
             reduce this problem.                of the network manager to
             However, the decision to            avoid bad topologies.
             accept or reject offered             One special case allowed
             connections is based                by the topology rules is
             only on local knowledge             called dual homing, as
             (i.e., information held             shown in Figure 2. With a
             locally in each station or          dual homing configuration,
             concentrator), and it is            the A and B ports of a
             not possible to detect all          concentrator or a DAS
             the bad topologies. FDDI

          2  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991

 


                                                The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             are connected to M ports,           FDDI networks has been
             usually of two different            recognized by many of
             concentrators. In this              our key customers.
             case, the B to M connection         Digital chose the tree
             becomes active, and the             /dual ring of trees
             A to M connection remains           architecture implemented
             in a "standby" state. The           with concentrators over a
             standby connection is not           purely dual ring approach
             part of the ring, but it            because this architecture
             can quickly change to the           offers:
             active state if the B to            o  Support for industry-
             M connection breaks. In                standard radial wiring
             this way, connectivity is              practices
             maintained when failures
             occur.                              o  Manageability

              We next present the reasons        o  Configuration
             Digital chose the dual                 flexibility

             ring of trees topology              o  A definable demarcation
             over the dual ring topology            point between the end
             and examine the resultant              user and the backbone
             need for a concentrator.            o  Scalability
             A detailed discussion of
             the development of the               Although the specific
             DECconcentrator 500 product         behavior of an FDDI
             follows.                            concentrator is relatively
                                                 new, the concept is not.
          Digital's Choice of the Dual           Most system vendors and
          Ring of Trees Topology                 users of large systems
                                                 have adopted the use of
              A dual ring topology               manageable hubs (multiport
             consisting of dual                  repeaters) for Ethernet
             attachment stations may be          networks and media access
             appropriate in very small           units (a type of passive
             networks that do not use            concentrator composed of
             structured and permanent            bypass relays) in token
             cable plants. But a dual            ring networks.

             ring of trees topology,              Initially, cost was a major
             using single attachment             concern in the decision
             stations as the end-user            to implement a tree-type
             devices and concentrators           architecture. Some users
             as hubs, provides the               saw the addition of the
             optimal solution for a              concentrator as an added
             highly flexible, reliable,          cost burden. However,
             available, maintainable,            the cost increase, which
             and robust FDDI LAN. As             can be amortized over
             described in the preceding          the entire network, is
             section, the concentrator           greatly outweighed by the
             is the cornerstone of               added advantages. With a
             an FDDI network. Its                concentrator, stations
             significance in building            can be separated into
             large, robust, and most             two categories, end-user
             importantly manageable              devices and backbone

                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  3

 


           The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             devices. This is especially         inadvertent disruption
             important in large networks         caused by the end user.
             where the functions of
             network administration               As shown in Figure
             and users of the LAN are            3, the actual number
             totally disparate. The              of components that are
             concentrator becomes a tool         required to connect eight
             that simplifies the role            FDDI stations, whether into
             of network managers. As a           the dual ring or in the
             demarcation point between           tree, is approximately the
             end-user devices and the            same; only the distribution
             backbone, the concentrator          of these components is
             protects the backbone from          different.

              In both topologies we have         network, made possible by
             eight physical connections.         the concentrator.
             A physical connection,               A large network of
             whether in the tree or in           many stations has a
             the dual ring, is a point-          high probability of
             to-point, full-duplex path          disruptions. Although a
             between adjacent physical           DAS and a concentrator are
             layers. The initial                 fundamentally different,
             reasoning for a dual,               they have in common the
             counter rotating ring was           role of controlling the
             to create a bidirectional           network topology through
             data path between adjacent          PHY-level signaling. In
             stations in which the               the case of a disruption,
             secondary path's main               whether an operator-
             purpose is to assist in             initiated function (i.e.,
             startup, initialization,            a station powered down,
             and reconfiguration of the          installed, or removed) or
             primary ring.                       a failure of the station

              Either topology requires           or cable, the token path
             roughly the same number             is modified according to
             of components, i.e.,                the station management
             PHY entities, optical               /connection management (SMT
             transceivers, cables.               /CMT) algorithm to maintain
             With the tree, the PHYs             a continuous logical ring.
             are rearranged so that               The main difference between
             conceptually we have taken          the two approaches to
             a PHY entity from each DAS,         solving the disruption
             in conjunction with a data          problem is in the way a
             path switch, to create the          station is bypassed. With
             concentrator. This approach         the dual ring approach
             does incur the additional           shown in Figure 4, when
             cost of the power and               a disruption occurs, the
             packaging. However, from            stations adjacent to the
             the perspective of the              disruption bypass the
             network administrator,              offending station(s) and
             this small incremental              reconfigure the ring by
             cost is offset by the               wrapping the secondary and
             increased ability to                primary rings to form a
             manage and control the              new single continuous ring.

          4  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991

 


                                                The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             This provides a degree
             of fault tolerance but is
             limited to only a single            be limited to the stations
             disruption.                         remaining on the portion
              In the case of multiple            of the ring to which the
             failures or disruptions,            management station was
             all dual attachment                 directly attached.

             stations adjacent to the             An FDDI concentrator
             faults reconfigure, thereby         provides fault tolerance
             creating multiple disjoint          in a different way, as
             rings. Even though the              illustrated in Figure 5.
             majority of the stations            When a station connected to
             in the network might be             a concentrator is removed
             operational, they would             or powered off, the failure
             operate over several                is bypassed through the
             disjoint networks. The              concentrator data path
             potential loss of the               switch at the PHY level.
             service access point would          Any one or all of the
             effectively leave the               stations can be effectively
             network nonoperational              bypassed through the
             from the client/server              concentrator without
             perspective. Management of          affecting the connectivity
             such a situation would also         of the other stations or
             be an ordeal, since access          the global topology of the
             to fault information would          FDDI network.





























                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  5

 


           The DECconcentrator 500 Product



                                                 demarcation between end-
                                                 user devices and backbone
                                                 is required to maintain the
          Structured Wiring                      integrity of the backbone

              To fully appreciate                and to minimize disruption
             the benefits of the                 to, or manipulation of, the
             concentrator, let us                backbone cabling.

             consider an FDDI network             The Telecommunication
             implemented in an office            Industries Association
             building environment in             (TIA), together with the
             conjunction with structured         Electronics Industries
             wiring.                             Association (EIA), is

              A typical building                 defining a commercial
             environment includes                building wiring standard;
             wiring between offices              draft EIA/TIA 568 has the
             and equipment rooms on the          framework as designated
             same floor and in between           in Figure 6.[2] According
             floors. The wiring is               to this standard, end-
             permanent and involves a            user devices in offices
             relatively large number             should be wired from a
             of end-user devices as              telecommunications closet
             well as backbone devices            (TC). All closets in each

             over moderate distances.            building then connect to
             Moreover, frequent adds             the intermediate cross
             /moves/changes occur in             connect (IC) or to the
             this environment, and               building hub for that
             the ability to move from            building. In turn, all
             one location to another             building hubs connect to a
             without manual intervention         single main cross connect
             or network disruption               (MC) or to the campus hub
             is desirable. A clear               in the campus.

             Single Attachment Stations          so that a disruption in an
              The tree topology, as              end-user device, such as
             illustrated in Figure 7,            disconnecting a station,
             facilitates structured              does not affect the
             (or radial) wiring as               operation of the network.
             prescribed by the draft             The concentrators in the
             EIA/TIA 568 standard.               various closets connect
             The end-user devices,               to root concentrators
             implemented as SASs or              in the building hubs. If
             DASs, connect to the                other backbone devices are
             concentrators located in            present in the building
             telecommunications closets,         hubs or communication
             which are maintained                closets, such as bridges,
             and controlled by the               they can also be connected
             network administrator. When         to concentrators in the
             concentrators are used,             building hubs or the campus
             the most cost-effective             hub, as appropriate. The
             user stations are SASs.             tree topology offers
             Connection to concentrators         the fault tolerance as
             keeps the end-user devices          well as configuration
             separate from the backbone          flexibility required in

          6  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991

 


                                                The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             a structured wiring system.         reconfiguration of the
             Also, it allows for adds            backbone is dependent
             /moves/changes without              on 200 devices. The
             disrupting or manipulating          probability of having two
             the backbone cabling.               or more disjoint rings
             Dual Attachment Stations            is much higher in the
                                                 latter case. Also, with
              End-user devices directly          DAS stations, the network
             attached to the dual ring,          administrator is faced with
             however, are not easy to            the impractical task of
             isolate from the backbone           directly controlling 200
             LAN. Both the end-user              devices.
             devices and the backbone
             devices are part of the          Fault-tolerant Configuration
             same physical loop, as           Options
             shown in Figure 8. To a
             network administrator,               Two fault-tolerant
             management and control of           configuration options
             the backbone becomes an             are available: bypass
             ever-increasing ordeal              relays and dual homing.
             because each end-user               Bypass relays may be
             station is now considered           used with DASs directly
             part of the backbone.               attached to the dual
             Even though rules for the           ring to provide fault
             end-user behavior can be            tolerance in addition to
             established, they cannot            the single fault protection
             easily be enforced.                 provided by wrapping to
              The availability of the            the secondary ring. Dual
             backbone is increased by            homing is an alternative
             the use of concentrators,           mechanism which allows dual
             since these are the only            attachment devices to have
             devices that form the dual          a redundant connection to a
             ring backbone. This benefit         concentrator when installed
             is very important for a             in a tree topology. These
             large network. For example,         two alternatives are
             in a network supporting 200         examined in this section.

             end-user stations on a dual         Bypass Relays
             ring of trees topology, if           To avoid the aforementioned
             8-port concentrators are            reconfiguration problems
             used to connect them to the         with DAS implementations,
             dual ring backbone, only            the FDDI standard offers
             25 concentrators reside             an option of using an
             on the dual ring backbone.          optical bypass relay.
             The reconfiguration of              While such relays are
             the backbone is dependent           envisioned to alleviate
             on only 25 devices. Also,           some of the reconfiguration
             the network administrator           problems, they may induce
             needs to control only 25            more problems than they
             devices. In contrast, if            solve. The inclusion of
             the same 200 stations are           relays in the network means
             DASs directly attached              added cost of components,
             to the dual ring, the               cables, and connectors,


                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  7

 


           The DECconcentrator 500 Product



                                                  As shown in Figure 9, the
                                                 end-user stations A, B,
                                                 and C are dual attachment
                                                 with bypass relays, and
             loss of optical power,              station B has failed. With
             reduction in interstation           B bypassed, stations A
             distance, and an additional         and C become adjacent. The
             failure mechanism. These            total link loss between
             factors limit the use of            these two stations, using
             such relays to possibly             a fiber-optic cable of
             very small, physically              62.5-micron core diameter
             collocated work group               and 125-micron cladding
             LANs and make the relay an          diameter, must not exceed
             unattractive solution for a         11 decibels (dB) to comply
             large network environment.          with the FDDI standard.

              Let us assume that the              For some applications a
             fiber-optic cable has               tree or dual ring of trees
             a loss of 1.5 dB per                may not meet the customer's
             kilometer (according to             requirements. The dual
             the EIA/TIA-492), and               homing topology, shown
             the distance between                in Figure 2 and described
             the communication closet            earlier in the paper, has
             and each station is 50              none of the limitations
             meters.[3] Since the cable          or problems that can be
             length between stations             imposed by the dual ring.
             A and C is 200 m, the                This topology is beneficial
             power loss is 0.3 dB.               in a large campus to
             A connector has a loss              connect remote buildings
             of 0.7 dB (according to             into the FDDI backbone.
             the EIA). Since there are           It allows standard radial
             eight connectors (labeled           wiring practices, with
             1 through 8 in Figure 9)            up to 2 km between the
             between A and C, the power          campus hub and any given
             loss is 5.6 dB. A bypass            building through multimode
             relay has a loss of 2.5             fiber (MMF) links. The
             dB. Since there are three           dual homing topology is
             relays between A and C,             especially useful with long
             the power loss is 7.5               distance links utilizing
             dB. The total link loss             single mode fiber (SMF),
             between stations A and              which span distances of
             C, therefore, is 13.4 dB,           up to 40 km. With the dual
             which is in excess of the           ring topology each span
             maximum allowed by the FDDI         has to be counted four
             standard. Note that with            times towards the fiber-
             the use of optical bypass           optic path length maximum
             relays, the effective               of 200 km allowed by the
             distance is limited to              standard, in the event
             less than 200 m, which is           that a wrap occurs. For a
             far below the maximum of 2          link of 40 km, 160 km has
             km allowed by the standard.         to be subtracted from the

             Dual Homing                         maximum of 200 km, thus
                                                 leaving only 40 km for the

          8  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991

 


                                                The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             rest of the network. Using          simplicity and reliability
             a tree topology, the span           enabled us to keep product
             is counted twice as it has          transfer cost to a minimum
             only one active fiber pair.         and to nearly meet the
                                                 time-to-market goal. And
          Product Development                    finally, the relatively
                                                 small and tightly knit
              The following sections             development team stayed
             examine the DECconcentrator         together from conception
             500 product development             through field test and
             process from beginning              first product shipment.
             to end, elaborating on              Hardware Partitioning
             details of the product
             functionality as they were           As the hardware block
             refined along the way.              diagrams were developed,
              Several key factors                several concepts for
             provided a smooth product           partitioning the hardware
             development process. First,         into modules were
             the architecture for the            evaluated. The electrical,
             DECconcentrator 500 product         mechanical, and power
             was chosen as a subset of           supply designers worked
             the generality allowed by           closely together to choose
             the ANSI FDDI standard.             a suitable partitioning.

             Several features which               The initial high cost
             would have significantly            of the FDDI fiber-optic
             complicated the product             transceivers led the
             without greatly enhancing           designers to select modular
             functionality were not              hardware partitioning.
             included. Examples of               A modular design allows
             these are "roving MAC"              ports to be added according
             and the ability to allow            to the customer's needs,
             stations to select the ring         thereby minimizing both
             (primary or secondary)              the initial cost and
             to which to attach.                 the number of unused
             Second, product management          ports. Since Digital's
             established a clear list of         networking products have
             priorities, requirements,           traditionally used side-to-
             and goals that allowed the          side airflow for cooling,
             development team members            a card cage that supported
             to focus their efforts.             horizontal modules was
             The absence of significant          chosen. Four ports per
             changes in architecture             module was considered to
             or product requirements             be a reasonable number
             during the development              by which a customer could
             helped the team stay on             increment a system. This
             schedule. The priorities            module, referred to as the
             selected were to design             port module, contains four
             for low cost and high               sets of the FDDI physical
             reliability, provide for            layer chip sets, one status
             ease of firmware upgrades,          light-emitting diode (LED)
             and strive for quick time           per port, one module field-
             to market. The emphasis on          replaceable unit (FRU)


                          Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  9

 


           The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             fault LED, and a small
             amount of support logic.

              One function of the
             DECconcentrator 500 product         end-user configurations.
             is to provide support for           Two basic configurations
             network management; this            are supported in the
             requires data link layer            DECconcentrator 500
             hardware. In addition,              product. A concentrator
             the DECconcentrator 500             configured with one to
             device must connect to              three port modules (4 to
             the FDDI dual ring; this            12 ports) can support a
             requires the A and B port           standalone work group but
             types. The DECconcentrator          cannot connect in the dual
             500 management module was           ring of trees topology.
             designed to meet these              A concentrator configured
             needs. By combining the             with a management module
             data link and A and B PHY           and one or two port modules
             port hardware, we ensured           supports the dual ring
             that any DECconcentrator            of trees topology and is
             500 device installed in a           remotely manageable.
             dual ring of trees would be
             manageable.                          Another goal of the
              The DECconcentrator 500            hardware team was to
             product also includes a             eliminate the use of
             microprocessor to execute           cables within the box.
             diagnostic and operational          This goal was consistent
             firmware. To minimize               with minimizing cost and
             the number of modules,              maximizing reliability.
             we specified that the               The use of modular port
             microprocessor and its              and management cards led
             support logic fit on                the team to believe that
             the backplane. The use              the power supply could also
             of an active backplane              be modular and plug into
             eliminates the need for             the backplane in a similar
             a separate control module           manner. To avoid potential
             in the card cage, thereby           safety hazards, the power
             reducing both cost and              supply module is not
             the vertical height of              accessible without opening
             the box. The backplane              up the box; however, the
             also provides the token             interconnection of the
             ring data path function             supply with the backplane
             which interconnects any             is achieved with the same
             allowable configuration             type of connector used on
             of port and management              the logic option modules.
             modules. The number of              The only cable used in the
             modules supported by the            DECconcentrator 500 device
             backplane is based on our           provides power to the fans.

             evaluation of customer               Figure 10 is a diagram of
             need. We decided that 8 to          the various modules that
             12 ports per concentrator           compose the DECconcentrator
             is sufficient for most              500 hardware.


          10  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991

 


                                                The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             Power and Packaging Trade-          open area in each side of
             offs                                the box. When prototypes
                                                 were tested, we found the
              Once we decided that three         improvements in cooling
             modules could support               followed predictions. The
             8 to 12 end users, we               modification also yielded
             focused on the selection            considerable reduction
             of packaging. Two basic             in acoustic noise levels,
             proposals were examined.            which allowed the use of
             The first was to modify             off-the-shelf ball bearing
             the Digital's NAC common            fans with good reliability.
             box which has been used in           Mechanical and electrical
             many of Digital's products.         requirements could not be
             The second proposal was             met by any of Digital's
             for a new box design,               existing power supplies.
             which allowed improved              The power supply height
             serviceability via quick            was limited; a unique
             access to all FRUs (field-          connector was required to
             replaceable units). The             interface to the backplane;
             existing common box design          and the available area
             was chosen to minimize              was determined by the size
             risk to the product                 of the card cage on top
             development schedule. The           of which the supply was
             necessary modifications             mounted. Electrically, the
             were the addition of a              supply had to provide a
             card cage for the port              relatively large amount
             and management modules,             of minus5.2-volt power
             provision for mounting the          to support the emitter-
             power supply and fans, and          coupled logic (ECL) in the
             improvement of the airflow          FDDI PMD. Fortunately the
             characteristics.                    total power requirement

              Cooling was also seen              was similar to that of
             as a potential problem              Digital's Ethernet-to-
             in product development.             Ethernet bridge product,
             The bipolar logic used in           the LAN Bridge 200. The
             the FDDI physical medium            power supply group agreed
             dependent layer (PMD)               to modify this existing
             dissipates a considerable           high-volume supply to
             amount of power in a small          meet the requirements
             area. Evaluation of the             of the DECconcentrator
             NAC common box showed that          500 product. The use of
             the grill area in each              an existing design was
             side had approximately 35           expected to result in fewer
             percent open area. Analysis         bugs, and this proved to
             showed that significant             be the case. Only one bug
             improvements in airflow             was found in system stress
             could be achieved by                testing, and it was easily
             increasing this percentage.         corrected with a minor
             Mechanical rigidity was             design change.
             traded off against airflow          Card Handles
             improvement to reach a
             compromise of 50 percent


                         Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  11

 


           The DECconcentrator 500 Product



              The module handle design           radiation. A "waveguide-
             was probably the single             beyond-cutoff" structure
             most complex part of the            was evaluated. This
             mechanical design, and              structure is a rectangular
             it had the potential to             extension to the handle
             impact the cost of the              with an opening the size
             product. The mechanical             of the FDDI connector.
             design team recommended             The design attenuates all
             modifying a handle design           emissions below the cutoff
             from an existing Digital            frequency and was predicted
             product. This essentially           to provide excellent
             meant stretching the handle         attenuation performance
             and making openings as              for all harmonics of the
             required for I/O connectors         FDDI signals. Testing
             and LED displays. Handles           of prototypes verified
             for both DECbridge 500              the emissions problem
             and DECconcentrator 500             created by the connector
             products are processed              opening and proved the
             from the same mold since            effectiveness of the
             only I/O connector and              waveguide structure in
             switch/indicator openings           eliminating the emissions.
             are different for the two           This structure was then
             products.                           included in the design of
              Traditionally, these               the handles for each FDDI
             handles have been made              port.

             from a plated cast alloy.           Logic Design
             Plastic offered the                  The logic design team
             potential of significant            developed prototype
             cost savings and weight             hardware as quickly as
             reduction. However, there           possible so that the
             was concern about the               diagnostic, operational
             quality of plating with             firmware, and common node
             plastic, as well as about           software (CNS) firmware
             the structural strength.            teams could proceed with
             The decision was made               hardware-based debugging.
             to start the development            First-pass prototypes of
             effort for plastic handles          the controller/backplane
             while using machined metal          module and the four-
             parts for the interim. When         port module were in the
             the final plastic product           laboratory within six
             was available, it met all           months of the start of the
             requirements.                       project. The GenRad HILO

              Another critical                   simulation software was
             factor in handle design             used in the module design
             was electromagnetic                 process.
             interference (EMI). Each             One type of bug was
             FDDI duplex connector               discovered in the first-
             required a large, 1.4               pass prototypes that was
             cm by 3.8 cm, opening in            not caught in simulation.
             the handle which posed              A through-hole component
             the risk of emitting                body was used in schematic


          12  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991

 


                                                The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             capture instead of a                 Concentrator Port. An
             surface mount body. As a            FDDI concentrator consists
             result, the layout was              of a group of serially
             wired according to the              connected ports, each
             through-hole pinout. This           of which implements the
             error was not caught by             FDDI PHY functionality.
             any of the software that            Key to our product was
             checks design rules.                Digital's PHY chip, which
             Thus, the controller                implements the physical
             /backplane modules required         layer functionality and
             engineering change order            supports the physical
             (ECO) wires to mount a              connection management
             component onto the back of          requirements for station
             the module in a "dead bug"          management. In addition to
             fashion.                            the PHY chip, the CDC chips
              On the four-port module,           (one each for transmit and
             the differential ECL                receive) provide the serial
             signal detect lines from            /parallel conversion, clock
             the fiber-optic receiver            recovery on the receive
             to the clock and data               side, and nonreturn to zero
             conversion receiver (CDCR)          inverted (NRZI) encoding
             component were crossed.             /decoding. The fiber-optic
             This logic was not included         transceiver, however, had
             in the simulation due               to be purchased from an
             to its analog nature.               outside vendor. Since many
             The problem in this case            mechanically incompatible
             was an inconsistency                devices are on the market,
             in nomenclature between             we tested the products of
             the CDCR and fiber-optic            many vendors. Fortunately
             receiver chip bodies used           for the product development
             in schematic capture.               teams, our optics group
                                                 was able to identify pin-
              The strategy of building           compatible transceivers
             first-pass hardware                 from two vendors. Dual
             prototypes as quickly as            sourcing of the tranceivers
             possible to support early           used in our concentrator
             firmware debugging was              ports reduced the risk of
             successful. Simulation              shipping products based
             played a key role in                on this relatively new
             guaranteeing functionally           fiber-optic technology.
             correct designs. When                Internal Token Ring
             second-pass prototypes              Data Path. The FDDI PCM
             were tested, only a single          process provides fault
             ECO wire was required               coverage and topology
             in the product, and the             rule checking between any
             product shipped with the            two connected FDDI ports.
             second-pass designs on              This is essential to ring
             all modules. The following          stability since a token
             sections examine several            ring is made up of a series
             areas of the logic design           of physical connections,
             that are unique to the              any one of which can bring
             concentrator function.              down the entire ring.



                         Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  13

 


           The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             Because connections between            the mechanisms built
             ports within a concentrator            into SMT.
             are not specified by the            o  Fault detection
             FDDI standard, they are a              /isolation. The
             critical design area for               controller/backplane
             ring availability. The                 and the PHY chip
             DECconcentrator 500 design             design allow the
             addressed this aspect of               DECconcentrator
             the product as described               500 device to offer
             below.                                 continuous service in

             o  Data path (port-to-                 the presence of hardware
                port) integrity.                    faults by isolating
                Adjacent ports in the               the faulty hardware
                concentrator interface              from the data path.
                with a dual-symbol wide             The diagnostics that
                data path of 10 bits                are invoked at power
                plus parity for a total             up or on command from
                of 11 bits. This PHY-to-            firmware (as in the
                PHY interconnection is              SMT trace function)
                the same interface used             have the ability to
                to connect PHY to media             isolate faults very
                access control (MAC)                close to the component
                in a station. Parity                level. The fault report
                checking was added to               is then passed to
                Digital's PHY chip to               initialization firmware
                ensure that intermittent            which configures the
                or hard faults could                DECconcentrator 500
                easily be detected. If              product so that the
                a parity error in this              faulty hardware is not
                data path occurs, the               included in the data
                DECconcentrator 500                 path. Two levels of
                device is taken off                 bypassing are provided,
                line to ensure that the             one at the port level
                entire token ring is                and one at the option
                not corrupted. Without              module level. Bypassing
                parity protection, a                is always performed
                hard failure on this                one level of hardware
                internal path stops ring            away from the detected
                traffic altogether, in              fault. Thus if a fault
                which case the SMT trace            is detected at the CDC
                function might isolate              component level (using
                the fault. However,                 a CDC loopback test),
                an intermittent fault               then tha single port
                in a concentrator's                 is bypassed in the
                internal data path that             PHY chip. If a fault
                is not protected with               is detected at the
                parity could arbitrarily            PHY level or between
                reduce ring performance             PHY chips within a
                and increase the risk               module, the entire
                of undetected data                  module is bypassed on
                errors and would not                the backplane. Note that
                be isolated by any of               power-up diagnostics


          14  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991

 


                                                The DECconcentrator 500 Product



                do not provide a PMD                It also provides ring
                external loopback test              scrubbing in case the
                except in a special                 MAC should have to leave
                manufacturing mode.                 or enter the ring while
                Fault coverage of this              the ring is operational.
                hardware is provided              Upgradeable Nonvolatile
                by the SMT PCM process,          Program Memory. To support
                which prevents a faulty          firmware upgrades over the
                connection from being            network, the FDDI products
                included into the                require electrically
                ring. Fiber loopback             erasable programmable read-
                connectors are included          only memory (EEPROM). All
                with each product for            code in the DECconcentrator
                isolating media faults           500 product is executed
                between the fiber-optic          directly out of EEPROM
                transceivers and the             since the microprocessor's
                fiber-optic cables.              clock rate is relatively

             o  Internal MAC attachment.         slow. In the first-pass
                A MAC is not required            design we used conventional
                for an FDDI concentrator         32K by 8 dual in-line
                to function; however,            package (DIP) devices as
                it is included as an             they were qualified within
                option to provide remote         Digital. In order for the
                management. The internal         controller/backplane module
                MAC can be thought               to accomodate sufficient
                of as a "management              program memory, we needed a
                station" attached to one         denser technology. At the
                of the concentrator              time, component engineering
                ports whose job is               was evaluating flash
                to provide control               EEPROM technology. Flash
                /status of the local             devices became available
                concentrator function.           in surface mount packages
                This attachment is               with a density of 128KB
                internal to the                  that met our needs. The
                concentrator, but                flash memory proved to be a
                must provide the same            robust technology; however,
                basic service as a               development of a flash
                physical connection              programming algorithm was
                to an external station.          challenging and required
                This service is provided         extensive testing. The
                by logic in the data             older EEPROM technology had
                path referred to as the          built-in logic to handle
                "null PHY." The null             the details of the erasing
                PHY provides a means of          and programming steps,
                bypassing the internal           but with the flash memory
                MAC if diagnostics               these details were directly
                should find a fault              controlled by software.
                in any of the hardware            In order to upgrade
                [MAC, CAM, ring memory           firmware over the network,
                controller (RMC), and            a well-controlled procedure
                packet memory] related           was developed. A firmware
                to the data link layer.          image plus the flash


                         Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  15

 


           The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             programming code is                 to identify ways to shorten
             transferred over the                the software development
             network through multiple            cycle. Code that could
             packets and stored in               potentially be shared
             packet memory. This down-           among the products, and
             line upgrade is provided            code that could be ported
             by a network device upgrade         from previous projects was
             (NDU) utility that was              identified. These early
             developed for the FDDI              efforts resulted in the
             products. Once the entire           common use of the real
             image is received in                time operating system
             packet memory, it is                (RTOS), common FDDI chip
             checked against a cyclic            diagnostics, diagnostic
             redundancy check (CRC)              error logger, diagnostic
             included in the image.              dispatcher, and common
             If the CRC is correct and           node software (CNS). In
             the firmware image is of            addition to the code that
             the correct type (destined          is common among the FDDI
             for this product), the              product set, much time was
             DECconcentrator 500 product         saved by porting portions
             takes itself off line.              of the remote bridge
             The 68000 microprocessor            management software (RBMS)
             then executes the flash             responder and maintenance
             programming firmware                operation protocol (MOP)
             directly from packet memory         from the LAN Bridge 200
             to load the new image. Once         product. The management
             the load is complete, the           model for the data link
             firmware forces a reset,            and physical layer entities
             and a power-up self-test            for both the DECbridge 500
             is run that includes a CRC          and DECconcentrator 500
             check of the contents of            products was developed to
             flash memory.                       ensure commonality between
             Software Design Issues              the two products.

              Essential to the completion         Field Test. The field
             of the development                  test provided valuable
             process was the use                 information regarding the
             of common software and              quality of the products.
             the field testing of                Several of the sites chosen
             the DECconcentrator 500             to field test the FDDI
             product.                            backbone products were
                                                 technically knowledgeable
              Common Software. Early in          about networking. They
             the development process             were able to perform
             it was clear that the               specific testing while
             aggressive time-to-                 monitoring their networks.
             market goals for the                As a result, detailed
             FDDI product set would              test information was
             require the development             provided to engineering.
             team to be resourceful.             One engineer was assigned
             In the beginning of                 to each field test site
             the development cycle a             as a "site parent." The
             significant effort was made         site parents monitored


          16  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991

 


                                                The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             their sites and channeled           o  Providing a thorough
             the information back to                testing process for
             engineering. This structure            both hardware and
             for supporting the field               software which tested
             test enabled engineering               the product in realistic
             to react quickly to the                environments with a
             needs of the sites as                  process in place to
             well as act on problems                correct problems and
             found. This testing and                verify fixes quickly.
             feedback, coupled with                 We had quite robust
             the capability to load new             products at the time of
             firmware revisions over                first customer shipment
             the network, was crucial to            as a result of our test
             achieving quality prior to             /fix/verify process.
             first customer shipment.

                                              Acknowledgments
          Conclusions                             People from many

              The dual ring of trees             organizations worked
             topology is well suited             together to achieve the
             for all FDDI environments           development of the product
             that require fault                  on time. The key members of
             tolerance, scalability,             the engineering design team
             and flexibility of                  were Dave Benson, Gerry
             configuration. This                 Capone, Stan Chmielecki,
             topology is the right               Paul Ciarfella, Alison
             choice for managing the             Coolidge, Janis Roth
             ever-growing local area             Cooper, Joe Dagdigian, Tom
             networks through the 1990s.         Ertel, Cheryl Galvin, Dave
              Several factors proved to          Hyre, John Iannarone, Bill
             be crucial to meeting both          McCarthy, Charlie McDonald,
             functional and time-to-             Dick Muse, Luc Pariseau,
             market requirements with a          Dave Sawyer, and Karen
             quality DECconcentrator 500         Shay.

             product.
             o  Establishing                  References

                architecture and product         o  FDDI Station Management
                feature requirements                (SMT) Preliminary
                early and maintaining               Draft Proposed American
                these with minimal                  National Standard,ANSI
                changes.                            X3T9/90-078, Rev. 6.2

             o  Establishing and                    (May 1990).
                maintaining a close-knit         o  Building Wiring Standard
                product development team            for Industrial and
                with good communication             Commercial Use, EIA
                channels.                           /TIA 568, PN1907-

             o  Leveraging wherever                 B (Washington, DC:
                possible from proven                Electronics Industries
                and available designs,              Association, Engineering
                making incremental                  Department, forthcoming
                improvements as needed.             1990).

                         Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991  17

 


           The DECconcentrator 500 Product



             o  Detailed Specification
                for 62.5-m Core Diameter
                /125-m Cladding Diameter
                Class Ia Multimode,
                Graded Index Optical
                Waveguide Fibers,
                ANSI/EIA/TIA-492AAAA-
                1989 (Washington, DC:
                Electronics Industries
                Association, Engineering
                Department, 1989).












































          18  Digital Technical Journal Vol. 3 No. 2 Spring 1991
=============================================================================
Copyright 1991 Digital Equipment Corporation.  Forwarding and copying of this 
article is permitted for personal and educational purposes without fee 
provided that Digital Equipment Corporation's copyright is retained with the 
article and that the content is not modified. This article is not to be 
distributed for commercial advantage. Abstracting with credit of Digital 
Equipment Corporation's authorship is permitted.  All rights reserved.
=============================================================================
