A From:	SMTP%"RELAY-INFO-VAX@CRVAX.SRI.COM" 21-JUN-1993 18:48:53.38  To:	EVERHART CC:	2 Subj:	SERIOUS problem with CISCO/Decnet phase IV/V  ! Date: Mon, 21 JUN 93 19:04:54 GMT   From: WILLIAMS_B@snd01.pcr.co.uk" To: Info-VAX <Info-VAX@kl.sri.com>5 Subject: SERIOUS problem with CISCO/Decnet phase IV/V & X-Reply-to: williams_b@snd01.pcr.co.uk X-App-Relay: uknet.ac.uk) X-Usenet: ..mcsun!uknet!pfizer!williams_b  X-Name: Brian Williams X-Service: Sandwich VAX 8600> X-Address: Pfizer Central Research, Sandwich, Kent CT13 9NJ UK# X-Telephone: Sandwich (0304) 616223 & X-UK: Brian Williams <uk.co.pcr.snd01>    H This message is addressed to all CISCO router owners who will be running* multi-area Decnet within the next 2 years.  K We have a CISCO backbone and have been investigating a transition plan from L Phase IV to Phase V (Decnet/OSI). I have just come back from Atlanta where IH have been researching what needs to be done, and it seems that there areN serious problems with migrating to Phase V if you have CISCO backbone routers.C The problem is that the method that Dec uses to translate PIV to PV K differs from that used by CISCO.  The result is that if you want to migrate K gradually, it is possible for Ph.IV adjacencies in different area to not be  propagated across the network.  L The problem is recognised by both Dec and Cisco. The ideal solution would beN for Cisco to change their method of translating Ph.IV-Ph.V to the way that DecK do it; however, I gather that this does not have a very high work priority.   M I am concerned because Phase IV will be frozen soon. It's status within about I 18 months will become like that of Phase III. It will still work, but the I expertise in Dec to support it will atrophy.  It will not be available on : Alphas. Decnet/OSI _will_ be  _the_ Decnet within 2 years.  E I fear that if this problem is not dealt with in this timeframe, then F migration to Phase V is going to be a very messy business, very likelyO involving the use of some form of static routing. It is in the interests of all L Cisco users who envisage migration to Phase V to contact Cisco and raise theK profile of this problem, and hopefully resources will then be found to deal 	 with it.    F Disclaimer: these are my opinions, not necessarily that of my company.K However, I would love for Cisco or Dec to tell me that I am wrong, in which 2 case I will publish a full retraction and apology.   Brian Williams  