X From:	CRDGW2::CRDGW2::MRGATE::"SMTP::UTKCS2.CS.UTK.EDU::SHUFORD" 15-SEP-1990 23:18:59.67 To:	MRGATE::"ARISIA::EVERHART" CC:	 Subj:	No Subject  * Received:  by crdgw1.ge.com (5.57/GE 1.73)) 	 id AA01156; Sat, 15 Sep 90 22:44:02 EDT 9 Resent-From: @UTKCS2.CS.UTK.EDU:shuford@utkcs2.cs.utk.edu J Received: from UTKCS2.CS.UTK.EDU by DRYCAS.CLUB.CC.CMU.EDU; Sat, 15 Sep 90
  22:32 ESTJ Received: by utkcs2.cs.utk.edu (5.61++/2.3-UTK) id AA03432; Sat, 15 Sep 90  22:31:51 -0400 % Resent-Date: Sat, 15 Sep 90 22:33 EST # Date: Sat, 15 Sep 90 22:31:51 -0400  From: shuford@UTKCS2.CS.UTK.EDU - Resent-To: VMSNET-LIST@DRYCAS.CLUB.CC.CMU.EDU ! To: vmsnet@DRYCAS.CLUB.CC.CMU.EDU > Resent-Message-Id: <339CB0DAD8AF004C18@DRYCAS.CLUB.CC.CMU.EDU>2 Message-Id: <9009160231.AA03432@utkcs2.cs.utk.edu>3 X-Envelope-To: everhart%arisia.decnet@CRDGW1.GE.COM ' X-Vms-To: vmsnet@DRYCAS.CLUB.CC.CMU.EDU   K The following text constitutes the first VMSnet RFD, where "RFD" stands for I "Request for Derision", analogous to you-know-what.  Feel free to send me 3 (or post) derisive (or merely insightful) comments.   
 ----------   RFD-001   @ Heuristics for Corresponding between BITNET and DECUS UUCP Sites   by Richard S. Shuford !    Department of Computer Science     University of Tennessee    Knoxville, TN  37996       shuford@cs.utk.edu   
 ----------  M In recent experience installing DECUS UUCP at several small colleges in North N and South Carolina, one thing that the faculty and staff have always asked is,? "How can we send mail to and from colleges that are on BITNET?"   I Certainly it is not too hard to go from the UUCP network \to/ BITNET: the G gateway at PSUVAX1 seems to handle it nicely.  But the ease with which  H somebody on BITNET can send mail back to UUCP seems to be unpredictable;G so much depends on the local software configuration at the BITNET site.   H For one of these DECUS UUCP sites, Lenoir-Rhyne College, I composed someE instructions on how to correspond with BITNET users, giving a locally C pertinent example, which will be included below in their entirety.    J To make things easier for mail outbound to BITNET from VMS Mail, the DECUSJ UUCP configuration file MAIL_REWRITE.RULES contains the following section:  L #___________________________________________________________________________
 [OUTBOUND-TO]  # H # Any outbound containing a "!" after translation will NOT be processed  # by the PATHS router. # - *@*.BITNET		mcnc!psuvax1.edu!\002.BITNET!\001  # L #___________________________________________________________________________  M (Lenoir-Rhyne's machine, "lrc", has a direct UUCP link to "mcnc", which is on  the Internet as "mcnc.org".)  G A user on the VAX at Lenoir-Rhyne can use this address within VMS Mail:         To:  UUCP%"USER@HOST.BITNET"  I and the address-rewrite routines will pass to the transport mechanism the  address   %     mcnc!psuvax1.edu!HOST.BITNET!USER   % The instructions to the users follow:   N \/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/  B Network Gateways: From UUCP to BITNET (and back, if you're lucky!)  N Lenoir-Rhyne now has access to the outside world through UUCP electronic mail.M But the UUCP network is only one of many different interorganization networks L (IONs) in the world that together constitute what you might call "WorldNet".L It is likely that some of the people to whom you might want to send "e-mail"J use computers that are connected to some different network, such as BITNET or "The Internet".  M In \some/ cases, it is possible to use a network "gateway" to cause a message 9 to jump from one network to another to reach a recipient.   K Someday, we may be able to get registration of an official Internet domain, L which will be called "lrc.edu".  This will make use of gateways more simple,J but, as of mid-September 1990, THIS DOMAIN DOES NOT YET EXIST.  So for the< time being you'll have to use the following rules of thumb.   J Suppose that you wanted to send a message to a friend at Appalachian StateK University who has BITNET access.  If your friend is named Jane M. Doe, she ! might have an e-mail address like        DOEJM@APPSTATE   or possibly        DOEJM@APPSTATE.EDU  I It would be possible to send a message to her from Lenoir-Rhyne using the 6 regular VMS Mail program, giving it the "To:" address:        UUCP%"DOEJM@APPSTATE.BITNET"  J Probably, Miss Doe will need to know how to send a reply back to you, and,M unfortunately, there is no single way that will always work to send mail from J BITNET back into the UUCP network.  Assuming that your username on Lenoir-F Rhyne's VAX is JOEBEAR, have her first try the following "To:" address       IN%"lrc!joebear@mcnc.org"   K If this works, it indicates that Appalachian has done a good job in setting J up its software for gateway use.  If it doesn't work, tell Miss Doe to askK her local computer experts for advice; they may know the local incantations % that cause the right thing to happen.   M In the last need, Miss Doe may have to do the following cumbersome procedure.   I (You may call this procedure "Invoking BSMTP by Hand", where BSMTP is the M "Batch Simple Mail Transfer Protocol".  It has been known to work from BITNET M sites that use the JNET software.  I'm warning you; it's cumbersome.  Use the K Extract command in the ANU News reader to put this article into a file, and & study it carefully before you try it.)  L 1.  Create a text file that contains the message text that she wants to send     to you.   K 2.  At the very beginning of this text file, put some obscure but important N     commands, which we'll see in a minute.  This string of commands will causeK     a gateway-computer mail agent to take the file and place it in the mail O     system on behalf of the person sending the file. (The mail agent is usually (     an automatic process, not a person.)  K     (Remember, we are assuming that your VAX username is JOEBEAR and she is I     sending from the account DOEJM on the computer called APPSTATE  (here K     we are also assuming that the text file is called JOE.TXT).  Here is an K     example of what the file should look like, beginning at the first line:            HELO INTERBIT.BITNET         VERB ON          TICK 1234 )         MAIL FROM:<DOEJM@APPSTATE.BITNET> &         RCPT TO:<lrc!joebear@mcnc.org>         DATA+         Date: Mon, 10 Sep 90 23:59:59 -0400 #         From: DOEJM@APPSTATE.BITNET           To: lrc!joebear@mcnc.org(         Subject: whatever the subject is           Dear Joe,   G         Thank you for sending me the message.  I'm glad Lenoir-Rhyne is H         connected to the UUCP network now.  Let me know if you get this.           Best regards,          Jane  	         .          QUIT  I     Be sure to substitute the proper values for the fake usernames we are K     using here and the "Date:" line.  Be sure to spell the first command as L     "HELO"--don't try to improve it.  There should be a blank line after theK     "Subject:" line and before the main part of the message.  Following the J     message text, there should be one blank line, a line containing \only/I     a period, and then a line containing the word "QUIT" in uppercase, as 
     shown.  F     The number after the TICK command is not important, as long as theH     sender makes it different for each message sent.  Be sure to put theK     < and > before and after the addresses in the "MAIL FROM" and "RCPT TO" I     commands.  Oh, yes, really these commands should be flush against the F     Left margin--they are indented here only to set them off from this     commentary.   J 3.  Jane then does \not/ use the usual MAIL commands to dispatch this fileK     to you.  Remembering that the file containing both the commands and the K     message is called JOE.TXT, she should use the following command to send A     the file from APPSTATE across BITNET to a gateway mail agent.   )         $ SEND/FILE JOE.TXT SMTP@INTERBIT   L     INTERBIT is the name of the gateway computer.  When the mail agent, hereH     called SMTP, receives this file, it will take everything between theI     DATA command and the period line and send it through various networks.J     and gateways until it reaches the mailbox called JOEBEAR (specified as2     <lrc!joebear@mcnc.org> in the BSMTP commands).  M     It is possible that at a given BITNET site the SEND command may have someCO     other name.  Users should ask their local experts how to do the same thing.C  M It may be that you will not really need this for users at Appalachian, but if.M you correspond often with many users on BITNET you will eventually hit a case5B where the only way to get mail through is to invoke BSMTP by hand.  L John Quarterman and Josiah Hoskins observed in their paper "Notable ComputerN Networks" (Communications of the ACM, vol. 29, num. 10, October 1986, p. 932),  G     "...there is no magic formula to get mail between any two points inTE     Worldnet.  It's a jungle with trails that may cross and conflict,C2     lead to the wrong place, or become overgrown."  G What we have seen here is a specific case of the general principle thatoJ sometimes there are difficulties associated with gateways leading from oneD interorganization network to another, and some one-way paths exist.   N \/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/   .....RSS