  
Sheldon Leemon finally reached the breaking point when he saw the 
Tramiel clones comments in the MicroTimes article; here's  what he's 
doing about it... 
                     ---Steve Plegge

---------------------------------------------

Wed Ju l 23, 1986
 
Since I did not want to write this thing in too much haste, I am writing 
separate responses for each of a numbe r of myths about the Amiga.  This
is the first part, and I hope to add one each day.  Some of the future
topics are:

  MYTH  2:  "THE ST DISPLAY IS MUCH BETTER THAN THE AMIGA'S". 
  MYTH 3:  "THE AMIGA OPERATING SYSTEM CHANGES SO OFTEN AND IS SUCH A M ESS
              THAT NOBODY CAN PROGRAM THE MACHINE".
  MYTH 4:  "THE ST IS MORE EXPANDABLE THAN THE AMIGA" 
  MYTH 5:  "TH ERE'S A LOT MORE SOFTWARE FOR THE ST THAN THE AMIGA" 
  MYTH 6:  "THE AMIGA IS JUST A 'GAME MACHINE' ". 
  MYTH 7:  "BECAUSE O F ITS FINANCIAL INSTABILITY, COMMODORE WILL SOON BE OUT OF 
             BUSINESS".

If you can think of other irritating hal f-truths, let me know.  So without 
further ado, I give you "The Myth of ST Superiority."
------------------------------------ ------------------------------------ 
The Myth of ST Superiority 
by Sheldon Leemon

There is a lot of controversy these day s over the relative merits of the
Atari ST computers and the Amiga.  Even when based strictly in fact, the
comparisons made du ring such debates strongly tend to resemble the four
year old's "my dad can beat up your dad" type of argument.  But the most
 vocal element on the Atari side is ignoring the facts entirely.  Instead,
these avid Atarians spout the "party line", an intere sting mixture of
misconception and deception, no doubt inspired by a strong dose of what
we in the industry call "Amiga envy".    Nowhere  is this line more strongly
espoused than at Atari itself, as can be seen by the interviews with
Leonard and Sam Tr amiel that in Mary Eisenhart's article in MicroTimes.
By chanting the same lame half-truths over and over again, Atari advocate s
have promulgated a number of myths concerning the ST and Amiga cpmputers
that are being accepted in some quarters as the gos pel truth.

   I would like to shed the light of reason on these interesting and quaint 
superstitions.  I cannot claim stric t impartiality, since I personally
prefer the Amiga to the ST.  But, I can claim an intimate acquaintance
with theworkings of  both machines.  I am a registered developer for both
machines.  I have had my ST since June, 1985 and my Amiga since September
 
of the same year, just about as long as anybody else.  I have read the
developers materials and just about everything else ava ilable for both
machines.  I have written two books about the Amiga, and plan to write at
least as many for the ST.  I have pr ogrammed both computers in C and
machine language.  I have experienced first hand the advantages and
disadvantages of both mac hines.  So the following observations, if not
absolutely unbiased, are at least grounded in demonstrable fact.  They are
not m eant to be the definitive comparison of the two machines, but merely
to response to the myths and misconceptions about the Amig a that run
rampant in the the Atari community. 

MYTH1:  "THE ST IS MUCH FASTER THAN THE AMIGA".  The first misconception
th at needs to be laid to rest once and for all is the preposterous notion
that the Amiga's coprocessor chips slow down its operat ion.  I will respond
to this absurd contention point by point, since it is so so widely quoted,
and so little understood:
 
   (1)  In some RARE cases, the Amiga coprocessor chips DO steal cycles
       from the 68000.  BUT, it NEVER happens when the A miga is in any
       of the graphics modes supported by the ST.  In 640x400 mode with 2
       colors, 640x200 with 4 colors  or 320x200 with 16 colors, the custom
       chips NEVER slow down the 68000.  Period. End of sentence.  In fact,
       even  using some modes that are not supported by the Atari, like
       320x200 with 32 colors, the custom chips have no effect on pr ocessor
       speed.  You can have the music chip doing music and disk I/O and
       have great graphics going on WITHOUT IN VOLVING THE PROCESSOR AT ALL.
       
       Sam Tramiel is quoted as saying "None of our modes steal any
       processing p ower from the CPU; that's something we weren't going
       to allow".  Of course, the way they accomplished that was to LIMIT
 
       their graphics modes to the same choices offered by the PCjr.
       They simply "left out" any modes that might give t hem trouble.  The
       Amiga put these modes in, and left the choice up to the user and the
       programmer.  For those si tuations where graphics power is more
       important than computation speed, the Amiga can handle a 640x400
       display w ith 16 colors--the ST can't do that under ANY circumstances.
       And of course, if computation speed is critical, you can cu t the
       Amiga display back to 640x200 or even 320x200 with only 1 bit plane
       for color (2 color mode).  This means  that there is only 16K or 8K
       of display memory to manage, a fraction of that used by the Atari
       display. The fact  is that the Amiga gives the programmer (and the
       user) the option of using as much as four times as much memory for
        the screen display as the ST, or as little as one quarter as much.
       Isn't it strange,then, that the Tramiels always a ssume in their
       speed estimates that the Amiga will always use MORE display options
       than the ST provides?  Is tha t their way of saying that 640x400 with
       2 colors or 640x200 with 4 colors just isn't good enough? If so, its
       too  bad for Atari owners, because their display resolution just
       doesn't get any better than that. 

  (2)  Even the sligh t (and highly overestimated) slowdown that occurs in
       the VERY RARE cases where you use all of the Amiga's graphics
        capabilities at once can be ELIMINATED COMPLETELY by adding external
       memory.  The slowdown only occurs when ALL of th e graphics are being
       used AND the custom chips are using the same area of memory that the
       program code is in.  I f you add a meg of external memory to the
       Amiga, the custom chips use the internal memory, and the program
       is pu t in the external memory.  No conflict.  Ever. No slowdown.
       Ever.  You might say that this gives you "Power Without the  Price". 
       By the way, adding memory to the Amiga (up to 8 meg) is a simple
       matter of plugging in a board on the s ide.  Adding memory to the ST
       involves carefully soldering memory chips on top of the chips on
       the motherboard,  and patching in connections with wire.  Dangerous
       and messy at best.  And the Atari OS does not even SUPPORT more
        than 4 meg of RAM, even though the 68000 can address four times that
       much directly.

  (3)  The most absurd notion o f the lot is that the custom chips SLOW DOWN
       the computer's throughput, when the whole point behind their design
        is to FREE UP processor time by performing tasks independently that
       ordinarily would be done by the 68000.  Graphics is  the prime example.
       Atari is quick to point out the RARE instances when the Amiga custom
       chips steal processor t ime when drawing graphics.  What they fail
       to mention is that when the ST is drawing graphics, ONE HUNDRED
       PERCE NT of the processor time is consumed in the process.  For
       example, when you draw a line on the Amiga, the processor tell s the
       blitter where the starting and endpoints of the line are, along with
       some other stuff, and then goes back  to serious computing while the
       blitter actually manipulates the display memory in order to draw the
       line.  On th e Atari, the program has to use the 68000 to calculate
       each point of the line, and to set every memory location on the p ath
       of that line a byte at a time.  While it is doing this, the processor
       cannot do ANYTHING else--in effect ALL  of its cycles have been stolen. 
       So even in the RARE cases when the Amiga's custom chips steal cycles
       (did I me ntion that this NEVER happens if you stick to the ST's
       rather meager set of graphics modes?), its 68000 still gets SOME
 
       processing time while the drawing is going on, whereas the ST's gets
       ABSOLUTELY NONE.  Just think of that every  time you see that ST mouse
       pointer flickering across the screen. Its 68000 is huffing and
       puffing just trying to  update the pointer display ("hmmm.. I've got
       to redraw these pixels, save the background display memory, then
       r edraw the background, save the new background and redraw the
       pointer").  On the Amiga, the pointer is a hardware sprite,  so the
       68000 just tells it "move there", and goes about its business. 
       The upshot of the above is that in many  cases, the Amiga will work
       MUCH FASTER than the ST.  This is particularly true during graphics
       drawing, when the  blitter does all the work and leaves the 68000
       alone to do its spreadsheet recalculations, or whatever it is that
        processors do in their spare time.  And in graphics-based systems
       like GEM and Intuition, drawing goes on ALL THE TIM E.  Moving the
       mouse pointer.  Moving and sizing windows.  Manipulating icons.   
       And most importantly, EVEN DIS PLAYING TEXT ON THE SCREEN IS STRICTLY
       A GRAPHICS OPERATION.  Since the ST has a bit- mapped display rather
       than  one that is character-mapped, EACH DOT OF EACH TEXT CHARACTER
       has to be drawn with BY THE 68000.  When you are printing  or scrolling
       text on the ST, the processor has its hands full, and can't do
       anything else.  On the Amiga, the b litter moves the whole block of
       bits for each text character, leaving the 68000 to do the job  of
       computing, not  drawing text.  A graphic (excuse the pun) example can
       be seen by running the BASIC program:

               FOR I=0 t o 255:?CHR$(I):NEXT 

       on the ST.  Such slow printing hasn't been seen since the the days
       of the TI-99/4A (thoug h in fairness to the ST, this is as much a
       fault of its cheap BASIC interpreter than it is the system design).
       A ll of a sudden, the ST doesn't look so powerful, does it?  Why do
       you think that Atari is trying so very hard to incorpo rate a blitter
       chip into its ST series (so far without visible result)? They should
       have thought of that earlier ....like Amiga did.

       In the article, Leonard Tramiel is quoted as saying "If you're going
       to do a graphics but  engineering-intensive program, DEPENDING ON
       WHAT MODE YOU'RE RUNNING ON, it'll run a factor of three times
       faste r on an ST than on an Amiga (emphasis added).  Hopefully, we've
       already exposed the fraud of that "depending on what mod e" business,
       since the Amiga does not slow down at all in any mode that is
       comparable to the Atari display.  We  must conclude, therefore, that
       the determining factor is clock speed, and as Leonard himself pointed
       out, the le ad of the Atari is at best 15%.  So where in the world did
       he get the "three times faster" figure?  Perhaps he meant if  the
       Amiga was running that application and three others at the same time
       (try that on an ST).  Because no known  benchmarks bear him out.  All
       of the benchmarks that have been published show at very most a tiny
       advantage to t he ST, consistent with its slightly faster processor
       speed.  Many, in fact, give the edge to the Amiga, showing that oft en,
       the benchmark is more a test of the compiler than the computer, and
       that differences in compiler efficiency  can easily compensate for
       the small difference in processor speed. And while the Atari may
       compute results sligh tly faster than the Amiga, heaven help us if it
       has to print them.  Or worse yet, scroll the printing.  The upshot
        of this is that the Atari is not the speed demon that Leonard Tramiel
       depicts, nor is the Amiga the plodding tortoise .  Hands on experience
       with both machines leads to a very different impression. 

 
MYTH 2:  "THE ST DISPLAY IS MUCH  BETTER THAN THE AMIGA'S".

The problem with this assertion is that most often, it is made on the basis
of comparing the ST an d its color monitor with a smilar picture on the
Amiga and its color monitor. This of course proves nothing, since it
involves  two variables, the computer and the monitor.  When comparing the
two monitors side by side, it's natural that the Atari displa y looks sharper
and crisper, since it's smaller (the old Mac trick).  Try running the Amiga
display to a 9" Sony hi-res monito r, though,  and your opinion may change.
Also, the Atari monitor can be matched very closely to the machine, since it
 is basi cally useable only with that machine (it runs only in analog RGB
mode, which is still fairly rare, and has a plug that is even  wackier than
the one used by the Amiga).  But the Amiga monitor is designed to function
as an analog or digital RGB monitor, a s well as a separated composite
monitor, so it can be used with an IBM-PC or Atari 800XL. 
 
The only reasonable way to compa re the video quality of the two machines
is on the same color monitor.  In all fairness, those who have run both
machines on t he same display still give a slight edge to the Atari.  But
this may be partially explained in terms of a design tradeoff on th e part
of the Amiga.  The Atari ST is designed to work with its own monitors,
and not much else, while the Amiga is designed t o work with every kind of
monitor (and TV set) made.  From the beginning, the Amiga was designed with
video applications in mi nd.  In fact, unless I miss my guess, I'd say that
the reason that the clock speed of the Amiga is 7.2 MHz and not 8 MHz like
 the ST is that the former figure is an even multiple of the 3.59 MHz color
burst crystal used in color televisions, so that usi ng that clock speed
makes it easier to sync the display to a TV set. 
 
Two years ago, when I first saw a prototype Amiga, I  was amazed to see that
it could display clear 80-column text on an ordinary (and rather cheap) TV
set.  When I reported that f act, I got E-Mail from broadcast engineers,
video physicists, and even some guy who claimed to have won the Nobel Prize
for TV  Repair, saying that it was flatly impossible.  Funny how I never
hear from those guys since the Amiga came out, and they can s ee it for
themselves. 
 
What difference does full NTSC video compatibility make in a computer?  Well,  
it does make it eas ier to hook the thing to a projection TV for a demonstra-
tion, something that I sorely miss when speaking to Atari groups.  It  also
makes it possible to use those great Amiga graphics for video titling on
your home video productions.  Or use animation  packages like the great
Video Construction Set to produce animated promotional videos for advertise-
ments and in-store displa ys (as many people are now doing).  And with an
inexpensive Genlock interface such as the one Commodore has displayed (and
hop efully will soon produce), it will be possible to use the Amiga to
replace about $50,000 worth of video equipment for less than  a tenth of
that cost, something that would be of interest to every cable TV company in
the land.  So you see, though accordin g to Leonard Tramiel "the ST was
designed to be a powerful, flexible machine, in as many directions as
possible", Atari seems  to have neglected the direction of video production
work.  By confining the ST to its own nice, crisp, (and somewhat nonstandar d) 
displays, it has ignored an extremely under-developed market segment.  The 
enormous flexibility that the Amiga's video ca pabilities offer to the user  
are, in the opinion of many, well worth the very slight advantage in display  
clarity -that it  cedes to the Atari when it comes to analog RGB monitors. 
 
The other part of the myth of the ST's video superiority concerns  its  
monochrome display mode.  Again, quoting Sam Tramiel from the article cited
above:  
       "there's no monochrome mod e on the Amiga, you can't run a 640x400
high-resolution monochrome machine.  So for serious business applications,
terminal ap plications, you just can't do it".

  Here we see two misconceptions expressed in as many sentences.  The first
misconception  is that a 640x200 display is not suitable for serious business
use such as "terminal applications".   For one thing, that is t he very
display resolution of the IBM Color Graphics Adapter, which is the current
STANDARD among business users (since the IB M monochrome adapter cannot 
display Lotus 1-2-3 graphics).  I find it odd that ATARI would argue that  
IBM's equipment is no t suited for business.  And those of you reading this
article on-line using a 640x200 display would probably agree that it is a t
least marginally suitable for terminal applications. 
 
More troubling is the fact that the vast majority of ST owners have  ONLY the 
color monitor, whose MAXIMUM resolution mode is the exact same as that
offered as the default mode of the Amiga Wor kbench.  For you see, in order
to make use of all three resolution modes offered by the ST (as compared to
about 20 offered by  the Amiga), you need to buy TWO SEPARATE MONITORS.  In
order to switch between medium and high resolution modes on the ST, you  have
to unplug one monitor, plug in the new one, and reboot the computer -- there
is no convenient way to make the switch, th ough hopefully somebody will
invent a switchbox soon.
 
And some of the software written for the ST's color monitor, primaril y game 
software, will not work on the monochrome display (though everything works on 
the color display).  So while the Atari  monochrome monitor DOES offer an 
EXTREMELY nice small text display, very few ST owners use it as their only 
monitor.  In fa ct, Atari has stockpiled such a quantity of monochrome monitors 
that they have been giving them away lately - their dealers ge t one mono-
chrome monitor free with every 520 and disk drive that they buy.  Therefore,
it seems unlikely that we will see an y software in the near future that
relies on the 640x400 resolution capabilities of the ST, since most ST
owners just do not p ossess this capability. 
 
One last point about the ST display.  While the color 640x200 4-color mode
has become the de facto  standard for the ST, in one respect it is the least
pleasant to use.  Because of space limitations (and cheapness), Atari opte d
to include only one set of graphics data for its desktop icons.  Since the
320x200 mode and the 640x400 mode have the same a spect ratio, they chose
graphics that would look good in those two modes.  In the 640x200 mode,
however, those same icons look  rather ridiculous -- they are tall and skinny,
half as wide as they should properly be.  All in all, they give the impres-
si on of an El Greco version of GEM.  So it is somewhat ironic that having
chosen to use only one set of icon graphics, Atari pick ed the set that
would look the worst in the mode that is used the most on its machines. 
 
The other misconception expressed  by Mr. Tramiel in the above quote is that
the Amiga does not have a useable 640x400 display mode.  Nobody will deny
that with  the current color Amiga monitor, it is not possible to use 640x400
interlaced text because of the the "jitter" of the low-persi stance phospor
display.  Even so, careful color selection and placement can be used to
avoid the problem entirely.  For exampl e, the Digi-View digitizer can create
black and white digitized images in 640x400 resolution with 16 grey levels,
and those ex tremely fine images do not "vibrate" in the least on the current
color display. Moreover, the user can always get a separate mo nochrome
monitor that uses a high-persistance phosphor, and enjoy 640x400 resolution
without the jitter. Such monitors are fai rly inexpensive, and recent changes
made by the 1.2 version of the Amiga Operating System enable the use of a
640x400 Workbenc h environment. 
 
The brightest prospect of all, however, is the potential use of analog RGB 
monitors with high-persistance  phosphors.  Several such monitors are on the 
market now, and Commodore-Amiga had them at the Spring Comdex.  As one who 
atte nded that show, I can tell you that the Amiga color display in 640x400  
mode on such a monitor is every bit as good as the 640 x200 display on the
current Amiga monitor, and the persistance of the phosphor was not high
enough to cause "trails" when the  screen scrolled.  While it is true that
these monitors currently sell in the $1000 price range, the same was true
two years ag o of the kind of monitor now used with the Amiga.  There seems
to be no reason why the price of such monitors cannot come down  to the same
level of the present Amiga monitor.  And there are newer monitors coming onto
the scene that can digitally store a nd combine the two frames of an inter-
laced display, creating a non-interlaced display from them.  In short,
there is every c hance that in the near future we will see an affordable
monitor that can be used for ALL of the Amiga graphics modes, including 
640x400 in 16 colors.  In the meantime, the truly fanatic Amiga user may
buy one color monitor for display resolutions of 640 x200 and below, and a
separate monochrome for 640x400.  Just like with the Atari ST.
---------- 
                                                                                                            By Sheldon Leemon 
 
MYTH 3:  "THE AMIGA OPERAT ING SYSTEM CHANGES SO OFTEN AND IS SUCH A MESS
          THAT NOBODY CAN PROGRAM THE MACHINE".

    This myth is a leftover f rom the pre-release days of the Amiga.  The
developers who had to work with the earliest versions of the Amiga had an
uphill b attle all right, not because the operating system was so buggy, but
because half of it hadn't been written yet!  Don't forget,  according to
MetaComCo, it was not until FEBRUARY 1985 that they produced the very first
prototype disk operating system for t he Amiga.  Until that point, you could
not even read or write a disk file conveniently.  In contrast, the ST was
almost ready  to ship to developers by then.  Considering the amount of  
catching up the Amiga had to do, and the time its developers had to  do it
in, its small wonder that the operating system was changing "every week". 
 
ST enthusiasts seem to be greatly amused  that the internal version number of
the Amiga OS is already up to version 33.  This amusement reveals nothing so
much as a lac k of any programming experience.  For example, a piece of
software for which I am currently writing documentation has gone thro ugh
11 beta versions in the past 6 weeks.  Since each one represents a number
of compiles, the version number depends mostly o n how many times you stop to
number the program.  In no way should it be construed to mean that developers
have gotten 33 diff erent versions of the Operating System to work with.
Only a handful of developers outside of Amiga ever SAW a version lower tha n
27.  The fact is, the vast majority of developers received the official
release version as their first version of the Operat ing System.  They, like
the general public, have been faced with exactly one revision of the OS
since the machines release (wi th another one in the works).  This record
compares quite favorably to machines like the Mac, and even the ST, which has
had a  similar number OS revisions since its release. The revisions have
maintained upward compatibility, so that software that worke d under the older
versions will still work under the newer versions, something that is not
necessarily true of the Atari (ther e are some programs that do not run under
the TOS ROMs that did under TOS in RAM, though of course, you can always
load the RA M version if necessary). 
 
Though the Amiga Operating System is far from perfect (and will undoubtably
be improved in the fu ture, since it is not locked in ROM), it is a system
that was designed for maximum flexibility and expandability.  There are
m any design features that support future hardware enhancements, such as OS
support for screens as large as 1024x1024 pixels.  Th e Amiga OS even is
designed to support the 68020 processor and the 68881 floating-point
coprocessor!  A third-party maker of 6 8020 boards, CSA, was able to plug
their replacement board into the 68000 socket of the Amiga and get it to run
AmigaDOS with  no modification. Needless to say, the ST's version of GEM will
have to be completely re-written for the 68020, making it highly  unlikely
that current versions of ST software will ever benefit from the speed of
the '020.  Some programs may be ported, and  present ST owners who upgrade
to an '020 box using their current ST as a terminal will still be able run
the software on the  68000 side, but you will not be able to just stick an
'020 in the box and have the software run like you can do with the Amiga. 
Ditto for '881 floating-point coprocessor support. 
 
The virtues of the Amiga Operating System (and its faults) are too num erous
to discuss here in detail, but we cannot move on without mentioning the one
feature that the Atari community is most anx ious to overlook -- multitasking.
This feature alone raises the Amiga OS to entirely different plane than that
of the ST. Thos e who have not had the benefit of this feature may think
that since most of us are used to doing one thing at a time, multi-tas king
is no more than a flashy gimmick.  Those who have had the chance to use this
feature, however, think otherwise.  For exam ple, an Amiga owner recently
told me of his amusement upon reading the complaint of an ST user about a
terminal program that w ould not allow him to format disks while online.
With the Amiga, you can run a word processor, format disks, and play a game
s imultaneously while online!  Just think, never to be bored by a slow online
conference again.  And wouldn't it feel great to ju st pull down that window
to reveal the desktop, and start up another program without closing the
current one? 
 
Of course,  as ST owners would be quick to point out, GEM can multi-task --  
sort of.  There are always desk accessories that can be launc hed from your
program (though most of the time, you can use either the program OR the
accessory, but not both at the same time ).  And there are Operating System
add-ons like the soon-to-be-released Micro RTX that is supposed to add a
fair level of conc urrency to GEM (providing that all of the programs use
the GEM event manager to wait for events like mouse movements and the li ke).
But these are no real match for multitasking built into the lowest level of
the Operating System.  Such a system allows A NY program to multitask with
another, subject only to the limitations of display space and memory.
 
While we are on the subj ect of Operating Systems bugs, it is only fair to  
point out that the ST has certain problems in that area itself.  In the
wo rds of Russ Wetmore, a programmer who has worked with the ST as intimately
as anybody, and a man who is one of the leading ligh ts in the Atari program-
ming community, "I 'hate GEM.  I hate GEM.  I hate GEM.  Did I tell you that
I hate GEM?".  Although  Russ may have put it too strongly, he does have a
point.  From a programmer's standpoint, GEM can be cumbersome to work with.
 But what is far worse than GEM is Atari's implementation of it.  Or rather,
lack of implementation.  Big chunks of it are still  missing, and not little
things, either.  Things like software-loaded fonts.  And virtual device
drivers.  Lack of the latter  is quite serious, since it is one of the core
elements of GEM.  Currently, the ST has global support for its own printers,
and  the Epson.  That's it.  As a result, application programs have to kludge
together their own support for other printers, the ve ry thing that virtual
devices are supposed to prevent.  So you have to track down a "First Word
printer driver" and a "Degas p rinter driver".

On the Amiga, there is global support for a dozen printers supplied with the 
system, and third-party and pu blic-domain support for dozens more.  And when
I say global support, I mean global.  Installing just ONE printer driver
makes  your printer work with ANY program.  And that means all of the special
features too, such as bold print, italics, underlining,  and custom line
spacing.  Of course, Atari has been promising for months that a GDOS addition
to GEM will be available Real So on Now.  This addition is supposed to supply
some things like the missing fonts, and graphics support for additional
printers.   But it will not include the level of global support for special
printer features found in the Amiga. 
 
Even if the ST vers ion of GEM was as complete (and bug-free) as the IBM PC 
version, it would still lack some of the nice "extras" found on the Am iga.   
Like user-definable keymaps.  A built-in speech synthesis device and text-
to-speech library.  Even fundamental things  like a built-in command line
interpreter.   

But there is no reason to belabor the point.  As we shall see in the next
sec tion concerning software, enough fine software has been produced for the
Amiga to belie the charge that it is impossible to pro gram the machine
because of its OS. 
  
----------

                 
MYTH 4:  "THERE'S A LOT MORE SOFTWARE FOR THE ST THA N THE AMIGA" 
 
To find out how much software is available for a  particular  computer,  
the  traditional test is to stack u p all of the diskettes one on top of  
the other to see how high the pile reaches.  Remember when IBM did just  
that to show  us how much software there  was  for  the  PCjr?  By  this  
measure,  the  contest is very close.  If you look at the catalogu es of  
available software put out by Amiga and ST for their dealers,  you will  
find a similar number of listing for each.   Likewise, the number of ads  
in  magazines like AmigaWorld,  Amazing Computing,  Antic and STart are  
pretty similar (if any thing,  there appear to be more ads in the  Amiga  
mags).   
 
Sheer  quantity does not mean much,  however.  I remember a p eriod when  
every time I would walk into an Apple dealer's showroom,  the  salesman  
would  start  in  on  how  there  were   over  20,000  software packages  
available for the machine.  I would look around,  and see only  two  or  
three dozen of th ose packages on the shelf.  What happened to the other  
19,964 I would wonder?  Are they storing them in the back room,  or ar e  
they just too dreadful (or useless) to sell?  When you come right  down  
to  it,  a  handful of packages account for most  of the software sales.   
So the best strategy seems to be to compare the most important packages  
in each category.   
 
 Word Processing:  So far the ST has the numerical  advantage  over  the  
Amiga,  with STwriter,  First Word,  Regent Word, and  Final Word to the  
Amiga's Textcraft,  Scribble,  and Write Hand.  In  terms  of  quality,  
however,  the call is a bit clo ser.  True,  Textcraft is something of a  
dog (though I've used its replacement, TextCraft Plus,  and it is much,  
much bett er),  and Scribble is not as fully debugged as one could wish.   
But STwriter is no GEM itself (pun intended, since the packag e does not  
take  advantage  of  the  user  interface),  and  First  Word  has  its  
deficiencies  too.  Let's  face  it  gu ys,  in  this department neither  
machine has much to brag about.  The top fifty word processing programs  
for the IBM PC ar e all  better  than  anything  either  can  offer.  Of  
course,  both  machines  have  some good packages waiting in the wings .   
Batteries Included is doing Paperclip Elite for the  ST,  and  it  will  
probably show up on the Amiga as well.  Atari h as just announced an OEM  
agreement  with Microsoft for a stripped-down version of Microsoft Word  
called Write,  and Wordpe rfect Corp.  has announced a  version  of  the  
highly-acclaimed  Wordperfect 4.1 for the Amiga.  So if we can all just  
sit  tight until Christmas (hopefully,  Christmas 1986),  both  machines  
should  have  software  that  can  be  considered  of  s erious use in a  
business environment.   
 
Spreadsheets:  Both  machines have a pretty fair Lotus clone available.   
In f act,  it's the  same  one,  the  VIP  Professional.  Despite  early  
complaints about the first Atari version,  the Amiga vers ion appears to  
work OK,  though the program allocates all unused memory for itself,  a  
definite  no-no  for  multitasking.   The  unreleased  Maxi-Plan for the  
Amiga looks interesting,  in  that  it  takes  advantage  of  the  user  
interface (mo use, windowing, pull-down menus).  So far, the software in  
this category for both machines is just adequate.  Close, but no E xcel.   
 
Database:  Again,  the most "respectable" product for both computers is  
the same one, Dbman from Versasoft.  And  again,  an IBM software clone,  
being Dbase III compatible.  Both machines also have databases that use  
the windowing inte rface to better advantage, but are less powerful.  In  
general,  there are a number of titles for each machine, but nothing to   
challenge Paradox.  We will no doubt soon see packages with more  power  
and  a  better user interface on both machines in  the near future.  The  
final score is that each machine  gets  a  "barely  adequate",  with  a  
slight  nod  to  the  ST si nce the Amiga version of Dbman is not yet in  
release.   
 
Accounting:  Each machine has some accounting software (Rags to   Riches  
and  Financial  Plus on the Amiga,  Sierra Online's One-Write system on  
the Atari), but again, nothing good enough  to dominate the market.  Dac  
Easy,  the program that has been a huge hit on the PC  at  $49.95,  has  
been  announced  for   both machines.  Again,  I don't think that either  
side has much to boast about here.   
 
CAD-CAM.  Let's face it.  Neith er Aegis Draw on the Amiga side or Easy- 
Draw on the Atari is AutoCad.  CAD 3-D is cute,  but not what you  call  
an enginee ring tool.  Dynamic-CAD on the Amiga may turn out to be a bit  
closer  to  the  industry standard.  Neither machine will take  over the  
market on the basis of current software, though.   
 
Graphics:  The Atari trio of Degas, N-Vision,  and Neo are n o match for  
the Amiga's Deluxe Paint, Images, and Graphicraft.  Tom Hudson will try  
again with Degas Elite,  which should  give the current Amiga crew a run  
for their money, but you can also expect a new revision to Deluxe Paint  
(Super Deluxe Pa int?) to follow soon afterwards,  which may make  Tom's  
reign a short one.   
 
One  area  in  which the Amiga clearly has  the advantage is in graphics  
standards.  Since Commodore-Amiga took the lead in  adopting  EA's  IFF  
(or  Interchange  Fil e Format),  all Amiga programs save their graphics  
files in exactly the same format,  which means that every  program  can  
 
use  the  graphics  output of every other program.  For example,  every  
drawing program on the Amiga can be used  to  create   new  objects  for  
Deluxe Print,  EA's superb Print Shop type program [Deluxe Print - JSP]  
(a  category  which  Amiga als o dominates,  by virtue of this excellent  
program).  You can also take the  output  from  video  digitizers  (see  
below),   and  read  those  digitized  images into either Paint or Print  
files.  And data base packages that let you use IFF graphics  fields  on  
the  Amiga  are  right around the corner as well.  The situation on the  
Atari is very different,  as each paint  package has its own format.  It  
is interesting to note, though, that Degas Elite is supposed to support  
the IFF standard  as well.  Bringing these two computers closer together  
in  any  way  possible  is  a  great idea,  since the real enemy is th e  
boredol machine from Intel and Big Blue.   
 
Another area in which the Amiga  firmly  has  a  lead  is  in  graphics  
 animation  packages,  since there are two for that machine and none for  
the ST.  EA's Deluxe Video is of special note, since  it is an amazingly  
powerful tool for putting  together  animated  promotional  videos.  It  
allows  you to put together ani mated videos featuring music,  digitized  
sound effects,  and a full range of video effects.  All of this can  be  
taped  on   a VCR.  There is probably less of a demand for such software  
on a machine for the ST,  which (so far) does not have an RF   modulator  
or any standard composite output.   
 
Music: The Music Studio is about it for each machine so far.  Users who  
 
have tried it on each machine seem to favor the Amiga version.  Neither  
are worth writing home about,  though.  Electronic   Arts  has  put  out  
Instant Music for the Amiga, but most are betting that its Deluxe Music  
package will be the one to bea t.   
 
ST  users  may  be  surprised  to  find that the Amiga version of Music  
Studio also supports MIDI,  through one of   several  optional  adapters  
that  cost  under $50.  In fact,  some say the Amiga version has better  
MIDI support. In addi tion, Mimetics is just about to release their Midi  
Workshop program for the Amiga.   
 
In summary, each machine has a fair  assortment of software, considering  
the amount of time that each has been on the market.  Neither  poses  a  
threat to the  IBM or even Macintosh at this point, however.   
 
 
MYTH 5:  "THE AMIGA IS JUST A 'GAME MACHINE' " 
 
This  claim  leaves   me  wondering  whether I should laugh or cry.  You  
would think that the words "game machine" would be never be  spoken  at   
the new Atari, since no company has suffered more (and undeservedly so)  
from that image.  And yet, in the interview cited  above, Sam Tramiel is  
quoted  as  saying  "The Amiga's a great game machine...  It's a great,  
fast,  low-end game machine" .  It takes almost unbelievable gaul for  a  
man  who should know better to dismiss a hardware marvel like the Amiga  
as not hing more than a toy.  If you told a PC user that IBM  was  going  
to  come  out  with  a true 16-bit computer that ran as fas t as the AT,  
came with a  built-in  880K  3.5"  disk  drive,  a  half  meg  of  RAM,  
expandable to 8 1/2 meg, a fast color  graphics display, built-in serial  
and  parallel ports,  and a true multitasking Operating System he would  
probably say "W hat a  great  business  machine!".  But  apparently  Sam  
Tramiel  hears  the  same  specifications,   specifications  remarka bly  
similar to his own computer, by the by, and thinks "You could play some  
really BIG game programs with 8 meg of  memory .  And  you  could  store  
TONS  of  games  on  an  880K  floppy  or  40  meg hard disk.  And that  
multitasking is really g reat for playing a WHOLE LOT of  games  at  the  
SAME TIME".  This from a man who sells HIS computers through Toys-R-Us.   
  
The  whole  notion  of a "game" computer that is not powerful enough to  
run "real" software like an accounting package coul d only be  supported  
by  someone  who  just doesn't know how computers work.  Any programmer  
will tell you that most of th e time,  a  business  package  sits  there  
loafing,  waiting  for the user to hit a key,  and when he does hit it,  
the pro gram can take its own sweet time responding.  Not so  when  that  
user is tugging on a joystick,  trying to shoot at alien mon sters while  
dodging laser blasts.  A  game  that  features  fast-action  real  time  
animation  requires  every ounce of co mputing power that a computer can  
muster,  because if the speed isn't there,  there is no way to fake it.  
Those  space  sh ips  aren't  going  to  come  screaming  down at you in  
formation,  and you won't be able to fire fifty blasts per second whi le  
dodging  them.  Did  you  ever  wonder why you don't see a lot of great  
arcade games for the  PC?  Try  programming  on e  on  a  computer  that  
combines  a  slow  processor  with  slow  graphics.  Those are the same  
characteristics that caus e the "serious" business user to tear his hair  
when he tries to get a really big spreadsheet to recalculate, or has to  
wai t for Auto-Cad to redraw a complex object.  Anyone who suggests that  
a computer that has the raw power required  to  run  gre at  fast-action  
arcade  games like "Marble Madness" cannot handle the strain of sitting  
around for millions of nanoseconds  waiting for some bozo to press a key  
on  his wordprocessing program is using his head for a hatrack.  That's  
like saying  the Lotus is a nice car for frivolous sports  like  racing,  
but that you couldn't possibly use it for "serious" driving chore s like  
going to the store to buy some milk, or delivering pizzas.   
 
                                                                                                                                                                                 