From:	SMTP%"Info-VAX-Request@Mvb.Saic.Com" 30-SEP-1994 17:05:36.86
To:	EVERHART
CC:	
Subj:	Re: Digital Insists that VMS Has No Future

From: Jerry Leichter <leichter@lrw.com>
X-Newsgroups: comp.os.vms
Subject: Re: Digital Insists that VMS Has No Future
Message-ID: <9409300258.AA27703@uu3.psi.com>
Date: Thu, 29 Sep 94 22:49:35 EDT
Organization: Info-Vax<==>Comp.Os.Vms Gateway
X-Gateway-Source-Info: Mailing List
Lines: 670
To: Info-VAX@Mvb.Saic.Com

Someone forwarded this to me.  I think it provides one perspective on DEC's
view of VMS and its future.

As always, one of DEC's biggest problems is that not only doesn't the right
hand know what the left is doing, but one of them is trying to do abstract
art while the other is cleaning out the fishtank - and all the while one foot
is doing ballet, the other is doing roundhouse kicks, the mouth is busy
talking, the ears are doing anything but listening, and so on, and so forth.

							-- Jerry

The Uniform Resource Locator for this document is:
http://montagar.metronet.com/www/dfwlug/openvms_world.txt

Positioning OpenVMS in an Open Client/Server World:  
Issues/Answers  August 15th, 1994
Ken Steinhardt, Group Marketing Manager, OpenVMS Systems (Ken Steinhardt @BXB)

Digital Equipment Corporation
85 Swanson Road, BXB1
Boxboro, MA 01719

In this document, I would like to provide some commentary to address several  
issues that have been frequently heard when Digital has proposed OpenVMS as
part  of a Digital solution.

These issues are:

        - 1) Is Digital committed to OpenVMS?
        - 2) Is OpenVMS "Open"
        - 3) If OpenVMS is Open, then why should I buy it rather than
             the Open Systems from your competitors?
        - 4) If I am an existing Digital VAX customer, how and when should I
             move from VAX to Alpha AXP?

1) Is Digital committed to OpenVMS?

Based upon Digital's own actions and statements, we can understand why a  
customer might feel the need to ask this question.  Until this past October  
12th, 1993, Digital had not announced any significant new directions for
OpenVMS  for quite some time, and had in fact made major public announcements
regarding  our directions for UNIX and WindowsNT.  While we are very proud of
our two  newest "children" (DEC OSF/1 and WindowsNT), it should not be taken to
imply  that we love our other child (OpenVMS) any less.  

Digital is committed to OpenVMS, and to continued enhancements for OpenVMS.   
When Digital decided to port OpenVMS to Alpha AXP, it was necessary to "freeze"  
OpenVMS functionality at version 5.5-2 in order to insure consistency and  
compatibility for our existing 10 million OpenVMS customers.  Digital was  
dedicated to providing the existing wealth and breadth of OpenVMS functionality  
onto a brand new architecture, Alpha AXP.  In effect, Digital was doing the
hard  part, so that our customers could experience the assimilation of a brand
new  computer architecture with unparalleled ease.  OpenVMS has now achieved  
functional equivalence between the implementation on Alpha AXP and the  
implementation on VAX, ahead of schedule.  OpenVMS version 6.1 for both  
architectures (Alpha AXP and VAX) is now available!  Thus, unlike the last two  
years when our efforts were focused on providing this functional equivalence  
between architectures, it is now time to again EXPAND OpenVMS capabilities.   

Some of the new capabilities that are planned for future release on OpenVMS AXP  
were "program" announced on October 12th, 1993, and further highlighted on
April  12th, 1994.  They include:

        - Full 64-bit data address capability.
        - A brand new file system for OpenVMS that will support the gigantic  
          files, high update volumes, and rapid recovery that 21st century
          applications will require to be viable.   

          This new file system will provide new features that lend themselves
          extremely well to supporting Business Critical Open Client/Server
          Computing, such as:

                - A new approach to how data is physically written to disks that
                  could provide up to 10X performance improvement over how data
                  is written to disk today.  This new approach, based upon Log
                  Structured technologies developed over the last five years at
                  the University of California at Berkely, may revolutionize  
                  the high volume OLTP market.  
                - Incremental backup to decrease both the amount of physical
                  data stored off-line and the completion time for backup
                  procedures.
                - Fast, tunable online backup facility to decrease system
                  management effort, increase user productivity, and eliminate
                  a potential source of application downtime.  Backup can occur
                  online, enabling continuous system operation!
                - All the availability features of today's OpenVMS Clusters,
                  with improved application performance.
                - High performance backup and integrated support for Polycenter
                  storage management tools to manage terabytes of online and
                  off-line data, decreasing the cost of large data volume
                  management.
                - Investment protection for both end-user customers and Digital
                  Business Partners by allowing existing RMS-based applications
                  to run with no changes AND alongside today's OpenVMS file
                  system.

        - A new, Windows-based Graphical User Interface for system management
          and administration functions, allowing a single PC to manage one or
          more OpenVMS Cluster systems.  This will become the model for  
          OpenVMS system management for the future.

        - Extended OpenVMS Cluster capabilities, including unique disaster  
          tolerant support utilizing T3 technology and ATM technology, and  
          low cost OpenVMS Clusters based upon SCSI devices.

In addition, many other new functions and capabilities are planned for future  
releases of OpenVMS, and they can be shared with customers and prospects
through  Digital's Proprietary Information Disclosure (PID) process.

Major industry consultants, such as IDC, and Aberdeen Group, rate today's  
deliverable OpenVMS environment as the best relative to all competitive  
offerings for providing the availability, integrity, security, reliability,  
manageability, and scalability required to implement business-critical
computing  solutions.  Gartner Group has recently positioned OpenVMS as the
standard for  Cluster functionality, against which all other systems will be
measured.   OpenVMS will extend its functionality with these new capabilities.   

With OpenVMS functionality now coupled with the industry-leading performance
and  price/performance of Alpha AXP, Digital is in a unique position to provide
value  to our customers today, and in the future.

OpenVMS continues to represent the overwhelming majority of Digital's sales  
revenue.  While Digital sees significant growth potential for our excellent
UNIX  and WindowsNT solutions, it would be financially irresponsible to not
pave the  way for a bright OpenVMS future, and new business growth for OpenVMS.

2)  I will only buy Open Systems.  Isn't UNIX the only Open System?  Isn't  
"OpenVMS" an oxymoron?

Customers that demand Open Systems tend to fall into two very distinct  
categories:

        - Those that seek the business benefits that "Open Systems" may provide.
        - Those that have a specific technology agenda and bias.

We believe that the majority fall into the first category.  This belief has  
recently been substantiated by a Deloit-Touche survey of over 400 CIOs from the  
U.S. and Canada, which was published in the July 1st, 1994 issue of  
Datamation.  These CIOs stated the most important issues to them for Open  
Systems were:

        Portability (65%)
        Development Tool Functionality (59%)
        System and Network Management Tools (59%)
        Compliance with Open Standards (55%)
        Security and Continuity (54%)
        Must be a UNIX environment (25%)

The key to success in todays Open Systems market is often more dependent on the  
DEFINITION of Open Systems that the customer ultimately perceives will achieve  
their business objectives, and less dependent on the technology.  Digital  
encourages our representatives to work with you to form a common definition for  
the business value of Open Systems, and propose whatever technology can meet  
those Open Systems business objectives.
         
While the business objectives for Open Systems will vary, they tend to fall
into the following key points:

     PORTABILITY

        - Can I develop and deploy applications that will run on other  
          platforms and other vendor platforms without change?

        - Will your solution support user interfaces that are identical across
          other platforms and other vendor platforms, so that my people do not
          have to be retrained?

     INTEROPERABILITY

        - Can I integrate your solution easily with my existing I.T.  
          infrastructure and preserve my existing investments in potential
          client systems and server systems?   

        - Can I share data, applications, and resources easily across all my
          platforms?

And most importantly,

     ECONOMIC VALUE

        - As a result of providing Open portability and interoperability, can
          I deploy low cost, commodity priced hardware platforms for my  
          applications now and without limitation into the future?

        - By virtue of these open capabilities, can I invest in products today
          that will insure the lowest cost of integration or transition as new
          technologies emerge?

The problem has been that all too often, computer vendors have not defined Open  
Systems from this customer perspective, but rather from what one might call,
The  Universal Computer Vendor Definition of Open Systems, which is as follows:

        The Universal Computer Vendor Open Systems Definition

          O-pen (oh'-pen) adj.
             A term used by computer sales and marketing people to describe
             products that they would like you to buy (e. g. their own)

          Pro-pri-e-tar-y (pro-pri'-e-ter-ee) adj.
             A term used by computer sales and marketing people to describe
             products that they don't want you to buy (e.g. anyone else's)

Digital architects OpenVMS in the spirit of the IEEE base definition for POSIX  
(1003.0), which stresses PORTABILITY and INTEROPERABILITY.  All major Digital  
offerings will strive to adhere to the major industry standards, both formal
and  defacto, to provide multi-vendor portability and interoperability, and to  
facilitate Open Client/Server computing.

The organization that has probably done the most to further Open Systems, and
to  provide a customer-oriented, non-vendor-dominated forum for the definition
of  Open Systems technologies for delivering the true business benefits of Open  
Systems to customers, is the X/Open Consortium, ltd., based in Europe.

The most rigid, formal tests of Open Systems compliance today come from X/Open,  
who themselves have now obtained the trade name for UNIX.  Known previously as  
the X/Open Portability Guide (XPG), and now as merely "XPG", XPG is a suite of  
thousands of tests for Open Systems compliance, constantly growing in
complexity  and level, that verify Open Systems full conformance.  Most major
industry  standard open technologies and definitions, such as POSIX compliance,
ANSI  language compliance, OSF/DCE compliance, etc. are  all SUBSETS of the XPG
tests.   X/Open is where all of the good work that is done by the multitude of  
organizations that develop Open standards (IEEE, OSF, ANSI, etc.) get
integrated  together for a TOTAL Open Systems environment that adds value for
the customer  who chooses to deploy real Open Systems.

OpenVMS today (for both VAX and Alpha AXP) has become the only significant  
non-UNIX operating system to PASS all 5000 tests associated with XPG3, and thus  
achieve the XPG3 base "brand" from X/Open, attesting to it having passed the  
definitive test for Open technology.  Digital has just recently reached an  
important milestone by achieving XPG4 base branding (the newest, and most  
stringent Open conformance test ever, over 11,000 individual tests!) with  
OpenVMS version 6.1.  Thus, Digital has achieved X/Open XPG4 branding AHEAD of  
several notable UNIX offerings in the market, such as AIX from IBM and SOLARIS  
from Sun Microsystems.  Digital's achievements to date in this area have  
prompted the following quote, directly from George Shaffer, the COO of X/Open:

        "DEC went through a Stephen King-class nightmare of tests to get XPG3  
        branding for OpenVMS.  There is no historical precedent for anything but
        a UNIX operating system passing them.  THIS BREAKS THE CORRELATION  
        BETWEEN UNIX AND THE TERM 'OPEN SYSTEM'".

The true meaning of this statement to me is that while most UNIX systems in the  
market (including DEC OSF/1 and Ultrix, of course) continue to provide a  
platform from which to build true Open Systems, OpenVMS has uniquely joined
that  elite group of Open Systems, as attested to by the organization that has  
probably done the most to build credibility for UNIX as an Open System.  No  
other entity (Digital included) has as much credibility as does X/Open to make  
such a proclamation, OR TO CHALLENGE IT.

Then is OpenVMS truly "Open", and able to deliver "Open" benefits to customers?

Virtually ALL of the major cross-vendor open technologies that have existed in  
the UNIX world and that facilitate the development and deployment of portable  
applications and interfaces exist NOW on OpenVMS (such as POSIX 1003.1, 1003.2  
1003.1b (formerly POSIX 1003.4), ANSI language conformance, ANSI SQL  
conformance, TCP/IP, DCE, MOTIF, etc.).  OpenVMS has passed the Open Systems  
"acid tests", such as XPG3, XPG4, and FIPS 151-2.  OSF/DCE is rapidly becoming  
the industry open standard for the creation, use, and maintenance of Open  
Client/Server applications in heterogeneous, multi-vendor environments.  Many  
people are unaware that Digital (from OpenVMS!) contributed 4 of the 7  
components of DCE to OSF.  In recognition of the growing interest in OSF/DCE  
among companies that are building distributed Open Client/Server applications,  
the DCE Runtime Services are now provided directly with the OpenVMS operating  
system at NO COST!   

If the customer's application was designed to be "open" and portable between  
different UNIX systems, it is now portable to OpenVMS.  It also means that a  
customer can now develop "Open", portable applications on OpenVMS that will run  
without change on most major UNIX systems.  Did OpenVMS offer this degree of  
portability and "Open" capabilities three years ago?  No!  Does it today?   
YES!!!!!!

Does anyone other than Digital believe this?  Yes!  IDC has published a  
comparison of major operating systems and how well they support both defacto
and  industry standard technologies that facilitate developing and deploying
Open  Systems.  OpenVMS is the only non-UNIX system that is listed as
supporting  virtually all of the major components, on par with OSF/1 and all
major  competitive UNIX offerings.  In the December 6, 1993 issue of
COMPUTERWORLD,  there is a published survey of how 164 I.S. managers rated the
major "Open"  offerings in the market.  OpenVMS was rated right in the thick of
the pack with  competitive UNIX offerings, and was actually rated slightly MORE
open than some  competitive UNIX products.  OSF/1 lead the pack with the
highest rating, and OpenVMS and WindowsNT were the only non-UNIX products that
were even considered for evaluation as "Open" in this report.

As testimony to the viability of Digital's strategy to take the previously  
"closed and proprietary" VAX/VMS into the world of Open Systems, both HP (with  
MPE/ix) and IBM (with OpenEdition MVS) have announced FUTURE releases of  
software that will (in the FUTURE...) support major Open components, such as  
POSIX, DCE, XPG3, and so on.  This is good news for Digital and our customers,  
as it validates Digital strategy, and highlights the importance of choice in
the  market.

So, have real customers successfully ported Open applications from our  
competitor's UNIX offerings to production deployment on OpenVMS with minimal  
effort? YES!!!!

Have real, new customers replaced their non-Digital UNIX systems with OpenVMS  
systems?  YES!!!

Have real customers taken staff that had exclusively non-Digital UNIX
experience  and successfully introduced OpenVMS into their I.S. environments
without user  retraining?  YES!!!

Have real customers that previously had mandated "UNIX ONLY" policy in both
word   and actual practice (non-Digital) introduced OpenVMS successfully into
their  I.S. environments?  YES!!!!!!

Are there real customers that are buying DEC OSF/1 AND WindowsNT AND OpenVMS to  
implement Open Client/Server computing?  YES!!!!!

Have Digital's UNIX products (Ultrix and DEC OSF/1) offered these same "Open"  
capabilities all along?  YES!!!!

Are all the major third-party Open database and Open 4GL products available on  
OpenVMS?  YES!

The good news is that unlike the competition, Digital offers a Universal  
Platform that runs three strategic operating systems (DEC OSF/1, OpenVMS, and  
WindowsNT), and support programs that allow for change between them.  The world  
is moving to Open Systems, and all of Digital's offerings are ready.  Digital  
declares that the operating systems wars are over, as Digital uniquely offers  
our customers choice and flexibility that our competition cannot match.  It is  
Digital's customers who have won the war.  

The Facts:

                - OpenVMS has been retroactively re-engineered to support ALL
                  of the major industry Open Systems technologies that  
                  facilitate the development and deployment of Open Systems
                  in AN IDENTICAL manner to how it would have been done on
                  UNIX.  Until February of 1992 when POSIX was first introduced,
                  and July of 1992 when XPG3 base branding was achieved,
                  OpenVMS DID NOT support this capability.  While new OPEN  
                  applications can now be introduced in EXACTLY the same way
                  that they would have been on UNIX, pre-existing PROPRIETARY  
                  applications continue to be supported on OpenVMS in EXACTLY
                  the way that they have been, with full investment protection.
                  Now that OpenVMS has achieved XPG4 base branding (AHEAD of  
                  several popular UNIX offerings), it is technically as Open
                  as the best alternative Open Systems in the market.

                - OpenVMS products (H/W, O/S, S/W) are now PRICED on Open  
                  Systems price curves, providing the ultimate true present
                  economic benefit of Open Systems.  Until the Alpha AXP
                  announcements in November 1992, this goal had not yet been
                  fully realized for OpenVMS.

                - OpenVMS source code is now available to be licensed to any
                  party that chooses to.  Until February 1992, it had been  
                  CLOSED and PROPRIETARY to Digital.

                - Real customers, with real Open Systems mandates, have recently
                  made OpenVMS purchases, and have deployed OpenVMS as true
                  Open Systems.

Digital believes in Open Systems.  Depending upon the definition of Open  
Systems value that you define, Digital should have a very viable response, if  
not with OpenVMS, certainly with either DEC OSF/1 or WindowsNT.  We acknowledge  
that VAX/VMS in the past WAS NOT OPEN by most definitions of the term, but that  
at great effort and expense Digital has retroactively taken what was closed and  
proprietary in the past into the Open Systems world of the present and future,  
while protecting our customer's investments.

In 1992 VAX/VMS was renamed to OpenVMS for three very specific reasons:

                - It now supported the major Open technologies for portability
                  and interoperability.
                - Source code could now be licensed from Digital.
                - Despite OpenVMS on VAX becoming functionally equivalent to
                  OpenVMS on Alpha AXP, the VAX instruction set is quite
                  different from the Alpha AXP instruction set, they are
                  different hardware architectures.  Thus, it did not make sense
                  to use the term "VAX" when referring to VMS on Alpha AXP.

What was VAX/VMS on VAX is now OpenVMS on VAX, ever since version 5.5-2.  
Customers did not have to change ANYTHING.  Now, with version 6.1, OpenVMS is  
OpenVMS, whether on Alpha AXP or VAX.

3) So, if OpenVMS is "Open", why should I choose OpenVMS rather than an Open  
System from your competition?

First, the obvious:   

Superior Performance, and Superior Price/Performance.

For commercial applications, OpenVMS systems have set the current World Record  
performance for applications as diverse as OLTP (the TPC-A benchmark), to the  
real-world applications from almost every major independent software company  
whose products run on Alpha AXP, to the Datamation batch Sort benchmark.  At  
each performance point, Digital has established absolute industry leading  
price/performance.  Digital OpenVMS systems currently hold the TOP 5 positions  
for price/performance for the TPC-A benchmark, and 7 of the top 10 positions!

Even for technical applications, such as for a very popular third-party  
mechanical CAD product, OpenVMS products are the leading platform performers.

Next, and more importantly, functional uniqueness that provides specific  
customer added value:

OpenVMS derives its greatest competitive differentiation where customers will  
deploy applications for business-critical computing.  Business-critical  
computing is typified by applications that MUST, ABSOLUTELY, POSITIVELY provide  
continuous operation, and where functional capabilities for availability,  
dependability, system integrity, data integrity, security, and scalability are  
paramount.  Business-critical computing environment examples might be those  
where the customer systems must interact with THEIR customers and suppliers  
(such as communications systems, point-of-sale retail systems, customer order  
inquiry), or where any system downtime would have dramatic negative impact  
(financial funds transfer, military logistics, power grid operations).   Not
all customers or applications will require "business-critical" capabilities.   
For those that do require these "business-critical" capabilities, OpenVMS leads  
the industry.

How does OpenVMS differ from the competition in delivering "business-critical"  
computing?

Digital has gone to great lengths to provide the ability to deploy Open,  
Portable applications that can take advantage of OpenVMS unique features that
DO  NOT compromise the "Openness" and Portability of the customer's
applications.   OpenVMS cluster functions are "transparent" to Open
applications, in that unlike  most systems from the competition, Open
applications DO NOT have to be modified  to take advantage of OpenVMS unique
capabilities for high availability, fault  tolerance, disaster tolerance, load
balancing, extended scalability, and  fail-over.  Only Digital's OpenVMS today
offers the ability to merge these  business-critical capabilities with Open
applications.   

Who says that OpenVMS provides exceptional functionality?

        - Gartner Group, in their recent base definition for Cluster  
          functionality, where they have chosen OpenVMS as the most functional  
          yardstick against which all others will be measured.

          "There is not another cluster in the market that has OpenVMS Clusters
          functionality.  I can run a completely Open shop with OpenVMS as the
          operating system.  I can run it easier with OpenVMS than the IBM  
          RS/6000 or SUN operating systems, everyone's favorite examples of
          Open systems.  No one in the UNIX world has the OpenVMS combination
          of real openness and real functionality."      
                        - Wes Melling, Gartner Group, May 1994

        - IDC, who in their continual multi-vendor functional comparison charts  
          have consistently rated OpenVMS as the most functional operating       
          system in the market.

        - Aberdeen Group, who in their Cluster functional evaluation not only
          rated OpenVMS #1, but rated OpenVMS #1 in 23 of the 24 individual
          categories.

So what about the 25% of the market (according to the Deloit-Touche  
study) that will only consider UNIX proposals?   

Digital is moving quickly to provide many of the Cluster functions that exist
in  OpenVMS today on DEC OSF/1 UNIX.  Existing DEC OSF/1 high availability
features  have been extended this spring as the first "Cluster" capabilities
were  delivered on DEC OSF/1, with many additional capabilities being phased in
over  time.

As the inventors and industry leaders in "Clusters" (all analysts agree), we  
will be bringing many of our Cluster capabilities to OSF/1.  Our goal is to
have  Digital's UNIX clustering capabilities continue to exceed the UNIX
clustering  capabilities available from any competitive offering.  

And to extend our ability to provide choice and flexibility to our customers  
even further, we will also eventually be bringing Digital Cluster capabilities  
to WindowsNT!

Digital has made Clusters "transparent" to Open applications on OpenVMS, it is  
reasonable to expect that unlike most of our competition, we will provide that  
same degree of freedom on DEC OSF/1 and WindowsNT.

It also means that it is reasonable to expect that our DEC OSF/1 Cluster  
functionality will rapidly continue to leap over the cluster functionality of  
ALL competitive UNIX offerings.

The THOUSANDS of satisfied OpenVMS Cluster customers that exist today are  
testimony to Digital EXPERIENCE and CAPABILITIES, and we THANK YOU!!!!

And just as DEC OSF/1 will gain some of the OpenVMS Cluster capabilities that  
exist on OpenVMS today, cluster functionality on OpenVMS will be significantly  
enhanced and stay on the leading edge of "cluster" capabilities by gaining new  
functions, as described earlier.

Finally, to many customers, "Open Client/Server Computing" means integrating
the  worlds of traditional servers (such as OpenVMS, UNIX, MVS, OS/400, etc.)
with  the world of PCs and PC LANS.  The business issues that drive Open
Client/Server  computing are the issues of integrating data, applications and
system resources  without compromising manageability, security, integrity, and
control.  OpenVMS  currently is the only major platform that IDC rates as
having superior PC and  MACINTOSH integration capabilities, while
simultaneously having SNA integration  capabilities rated as highly as those
from IBM itself.  Products like PATHWORKS,   Data Base Integrator (DBI), and
ACCESSWORKS differentiate Digital, and have  allowed Digital OpenVMS customers
to succeed in implementing Open Client/Server  Computing at a level where our
competition has often been unable to compete  effectively.  

4) I have VAX systems today.  Do I have to migrate, and if so, how?

There are multiple options for the existing OpenVMS VAX customer.  Our message  
here needs to be very clear, and very powerful.  There are 10 million OpenVMS  
users out there who we know are depending on us!  

In the last few years, and up until only recently, there had been some
migration  from Digital's VAX installed base to alternative offerings from the
competition,  most frequently either PC lans or competitive UNIX products.  
Many of these  customers have been very specific about their primary reasons
for change:

        - 1) VAX/VMS isn't "Open", and I'm convinced that I should rearchitect
             to "Open" (and more recently, Open Client/Server).
        - 2) The raw performance and price/performance of VAX is not
             competitive with alternative technologies in the market.

Only recently has Digital CORRECTED these two VERY REAL AND ACCURATE customer  
concerns.  As a result, our remaining installed base, at 10 million users  
strong, has stabilized.  However, without our clear and immediate communication  
regarding how we will help you into the future, we understand our risks.  We  
greatly appreciate your business in the past, and do not take "for granted"
your  business in the future, but understand that we must continue to earn it.

Several recent (and public) external surveys of Digital's present VAX customer  
base indicated that given a choice, between 87% to 94% want to stay with  
OpenVMS, making them possibly the most loyal group of customers in the
industry.  

We believe that THESE 87%-94% OF OUR CUSTOMERS WANT TO HEAR HOW WE WILL
CONTINUE  TO PROVIDE LEADERSHIP OPENVMS SOLUTIONS FOR THE FUTURE.  Many key
Digital  customers have recently made it very clear that without compelling
evidence to  support a bright future for OpenVMS, that they will most likely
change VENDORS,  and not merely technology.

Fortunately, we believe that our story and message is powerful, and hopefully  
compelling...

First, this past October 12th, 1993, Digital introduced new VAX products which  
in their respective classes made them superior to ALL competitive offerings,  
(even the best RISC technology that IBM, HP, and SUN can offer), for commercial  
price/performance.  These VAX systems run over 10,000 third party applications  
TODAY.  More importantly, on October 12th, Digital made a public commitment to  
future generations of VAX systems, which will continue to scale from  
workstations to data-center class high end servers and clusters.  Thus,  
customers can continue to invest in VAX with confidence that what has already  
proven to be the longest run in binary compatibility and investment protection  
in the HISTORY OF THE COMPUTER INDUSTRY will continue.  Digital is now  
announcing, as promised, several new VAX systems that represent leadership  
commercial price/performance in their respective classes, including the
MicroVAX  3100 model 85, the VAX 4000 model 505, the VAX 4000 model 705, and
the VAX 7000  model 700.

Second, and more importantly, with Alpha AXP Digital provides the VAX customer  
with the possibility to make the leap into the future of computing with the
BEST  INVESTMENT PROTECTION (while transcending computer architectures) in THE
HISTORY  OF THE COMPUTER INDUSTRY.

Digital's engineers have outdone themselves (and every other competitive
vendor)  by bringing THE SAME OpenVMS that runs on VAX over to the industry
leading hot  new RISC technology of Alpha AXP with version 6.1.  The same
system management,  the same user interfaces, the same software development
tools, and so on.  Even  though software on Alpha AXP is running against a new
instruction set (radically  different from VAX), and on a totally new hardware
architecture (radically  different from VAX), to the user, the programmer, and
the system manager, IT  LOOKS THE SAME.  Digital has done the hard work for
migration, so that our  customers do not have to!  This MUST be contrasted with
what customers of our  competition have had to go through in the past, and
might go through in the  future:

Digital:

        VAX introduced in 1977.  Still binary compatible in 1994, with public  
        commitment to future generations.  VAX/VMS was proprietary and closed  
        (and proud of it!), now as OpenVMS incrementally supports all major
        Open technologies and Open Systems pricing, with investment protection.

        Alpha AXP introduced in 1992, able to run OpenVMS with a subset of  
        functionality as implemented on VAX.  In May 1994, OpenVMS on VAX and
        Alpha AXP achieve functional parity with version 6.1, with public
        commitment to major future functional enhancements.

        Applications that are up to 16 years old are binary executable on  
        current and future VAX systems, and can usually recompile and run on  
        new state-of-the-art Alpha AXP platforms without source code edits.


        Primary Competitive Products and Status during same period of time:

IBM:
        - Series/1?
        - System 8100?
        - System/3?
        - System/34?
        - System/36?  
        - System/38?  
        - AS/400:  Recent IBM announcement of migration to future 64-bit
          architecture. Compatibility?...
        - RS/6000:  Future migration to new 64-bit architecture, PowerPC
          based?  Compatibility?
        - PS/2:  Future migration to PowerPC?  Compatibility?
  
      - System/370 and System/390 H/W
        -System 370? 434X/433X? 303X? 436X/438X? 308X? 9370? 309X?  
         ES/9000? System/390 architecture ES/9000? Future?       

      - System/370 and System/390 S/W
        - DOS/VS? DOS/VSE? VSE/SP? VSE/ESA?  
        - VM/CMS? VM/SP? VM/XA? VM/ESA?
        - OS/VS1? OS/VS2? MVS/SP? MVS/XA? MVS/ESA?

HP:
        - HP 1000?
        - HP 3000?
        - MPE?
        - HP PA-RISC (HP-UX and MPE/ix): Public announcement of future migration
          to 64-bit VLIW "Post-RISC"?  Compatibility??  When????????

SUN:    - SPARC with SUN O/S?  
        -  SOLARIS (32-bit)?   
        -  Future SuperSPARC 64-bit architecture????
        -  Compatibility?????

Digital products have made the jump to 64 bit technology already, and are  
available NOW.  All major competitive offerings will require FUTURE migrations,  
with unqualified incompatibility, to 64-bit technology.

In addition to protecting our customer's investments in people, training, and  
software, Alpha AXP offers historically unmatched investment protection across  
computer architectures for our VAX customers for peripherals (disk, tape),  
communications infrastructure (Ethernet, FDDI), and in the case of the VAX
7000,  even the platform itself.  For all other platforms, the new Advantage
Upgrade  program and Alpha-Ready program provide excellent upgrade options.

And as for the 6%-13% of the VAX installed base that have stated their wish to  
move to a different operating system in the future:

        Digital offers the best UNIX option, with many popular OpenVMS software  
        products now coming to DEC OSF/1, such as Rdb.  By design, Digital  
        language compilers have achieved unprecedented parity in their Alpha  
        AXP versions for both DEC OSF/1 and OpenVMS.  Any customer
        that chooses to move from OpenVMS to UNIX will find that their easiest,
        fastest, and least risk path will be with DEC OSF/1.

        Digital offers the best WindowsNT option, with scalable platforms,  
        Microsoft-approved service and support, and the most experience
        with WindowsNT from any full-service vendor.

        Digital offers outstanding PC and PC LAN products, with the only
        "RISC-ready" PC available.

Summary

Digital's OpenVMS products and technology today are the most competitive that  
they have ever been in their history.  Those products, coupled with Digital  
services, and Digital partners can provide for very effective business  
solutions.  Digital is committed to continued support for OpenVMS, and to  
industry leading functional enhancements for OpenVMS.  OpenVMS today supports  
all major Open Standards to build or run Open applications, and to interoperate  
with other open systems.  Industry analysts, such as Gartner Group, Aberdeen  
Group, and IDC have rated OpenVMS as the premier computing environment
available  for Business Critical/Mission Critical computing.  OpenVMS systems
currently  hold the world records for most multi-vendor data processing
application  benchmarks for both performance and price/performance, while
offering the  absolute, undisputed widest range of binary-compatible scalable
computers in the  history of the computer industry.   

OpenVMS uniquely offers what we like to call "No Compromise Computing".

Have your cake, and eat it too.

Thank You,
Ken
