From:	SMTP%"Info-VAX-Request@Mvb.Saic.Com" 15-SEP-1994 09:07:22.94
To:	EVERHART
CC:	
Subj:	RE: mail program --- can we give machines free spooling?

X-Newsgroups: comp.os.vms
From: tillman@swdev.si.com (Brian Tillman)
Subject: RE: mail program --- can we give machines free spooling?
Message-Id: <14SEP94.13571004@swdev.si.com>
Sender: news@esseye.si.com
Nntp-Posting-Host: terwed.si.com
Organization: Smiths Industries Aerospace & Defense
Date: Wed, 14 Sep 1994 13:57:10 GMT
Lines: 54
To: Info-VAX@Mvb.Saic.Com
X-Gateway-Source-Info: USENET

In a previous article, VMETZE@vmetze.mrl.uiuc.edu wrote:

>	I am not complaining about the protocol.  I am not blaming
>	problems on the protocol.  I have tried very hard not to
>	discuss the protocol at all. My original question was whether
>	anyone was aware of a non-smtp mailer that ran across platforms.
>	
>	I have simply tried to point out that there are problems with
>	the present system which have nothing to do with the protocol
>	and try to suggest that we get a better system.

When you first asked this question, I told you about cc:Mail having user agents
for Unix (Sun) systems, PCs, and Macs and that it does not use SMTP to
accomplish this.  As this discussion has evolved, however, you've described
desires that are unmet by any present mail system.  The problem of what to do if
the target host is down, how to obtain more feedback about delivery or
non-delivery and several other items are also problems that apply to mail
systems like cc:Mail (and VMS Mail) as well.  Your restatement of your original
question plus the messages which followed the original question indicate to me
that you believe mail systems not employing SMTP will necessarily deal more
effectively with what you see as deficiencies.  This isn't the case.  However,
every single player in the commercial (and most likely non-commercial) mail
provider business has considered each of these problems long and hard, because
they are inherent in the very nature of mail delivery systems.  The present
systems are well-considered compromises, each implementing the vendors
trade-offs.  Trade-offs are necessary because many of a mail system's design
criteria are at odds with one another.

May I suggest your company join the Electronic Messaging Association?  This
association, whose members include Advantis, AT&T EasyLink Services, BT North
America, CompuServe, Control Data Systems, Digital Equipment, EICON Technology,
France Telecom Transpac, GE Information Services, Hewlett-Packard, Infonet
Software Solutions, ISOCOR, ISODE Consortium, Lotus, Lotus ICG (formerly
Soft*Switch), Microsoft, Motorola, Novell, WordPerfect, and Worldtalk, is
working on providing the next generation of electronic message exchange.  They
can better help you understand the problems inherent in timely, reliable,
eleoctronic messaging and perhaps be open to any suggestions you may have on
solving the problems you see.  Reach them at:

Electronic Messaging Association
1655 N. Fort Myer Dr. #850
Arlington, VA 22209
Voice: 703-524-5550
FAX: 703-524-5558

You can also contact them via Email: use either X.400 (S=info; O=ema; A=mci;
C=us) or Internet (info@ema.org).

-----------------------------+--------------------------------
 Brian Tillman               | Internet: tillman@swdev.si.com
 Smiths Industries, Inc.     |           tillman_brian@si.com
 4141 Eastern Ave., MS129    | Hey, I said this stuff myself.
 Grand Rapids, MI 49518-8727 | My company has no part in it.
-----------------------------+--------------------------------
