REVIEW.TXT

Please complete, in machine readable form, one of these review forms for
each VAX SIG LIBRARY entry that you have been asked to review.  Send the
completed review files on a floppy or a tape to the VAX SIG LIBRARIAN.


		    VAX SIG LIBRARY PROGRAM REVIEW



Program Name:

Program Number:  (leave blank)		

Version:		

Creation Date:		

Review Date:		

Reviewer Information:

	Name:

	Affiliation:

	Address:

	City/State:				Zip:

	Telephone:

DISTRIBUTION PROCEDURE REVIEW

	1. ( ) Yes ( ) No	Were all files present and complete?  If no,
				please explain.

	2. ( ) Yes ( ) No	Were all files readable in the VAX TAPE format
				as distributed?

DOCUMENTATION REVIEW

	1. ( ) Yes ( ) No	Is the documentation complete?  If no, please
				explain.

	2. ( ) Yes ( ) No	Are there unstated restrictions or features?
				If yes, please indicate them and indicate how
				you corrected them.

	3. ( ) Yes ( ) No	Is the documentation easy to use?  Suggest
				reasonable reorganization if possible.

	4. ( ) Yes ( ) No	Is the program abstract appropriate.  What
				changes would you suggest?

	5. ( ) Yes ( ) No	Are there "dangerous" features which a system
				manager might want to disable before putting
				the program onto a system?  If yes, and such
				features are not described, please indicate.

PROGRAM REVIEW

	1. Operating System:			Version:

	2. Compiler/Interpreter:		Version:

	   Compiler/Interpreter:		Version:

	3. Memory Requirement:		KB

	4. Did the program files all compile without errors?  If not, list the
	   names of files which did not compile or attach listings of the
	   compilations.

	5. ( ) Yes ( ) No  Did the program files load correctly?  List names
		 	   of missing programs or global references.

	6. ( ) Yes ( ) No  Does the program perform as documented?  List any
			   undocumented program error messages or monitor
			   error messages you discovered.

	7. List deficiencies which might be easily remedied or any error-
	   detecting which should be implemented within the program.

	8. ( ) Yes ( ) No  Is the program easy to use?  Are the commands or
			   input data formats ambiguous?

	9. ( ) Yes ( ) No  Is the program documented internally well enough
			   for a user to make minor changes easily?

       10. If you have made improvements to the programs or documentation
	   and if this has been done in machine readable form, please
	   return the changed files as you now have them to the VAX SIG
	   LIBRARIAN.

       11. ( ) Yes ( ) No  Does the program require special hardware?
			   If yes, please describe.

       12. ( ) Yes ( ) No  Are these hardware requirements really necessary?

GENERAL COMMENTS

	1. ( ) Yes ( ) No  Does the program provide the same service as
			   programs already on the VMS operating system?
			   If yes, which ones?

	2. ( ) Yes ( ) No  Is the program title appropriate?  (e.g. is it
			   reasonably descriptive)  If no, please suggest
			   another title.

	3. ( ) Yes ( ) No  Should the program be submitted to the DECUS
			   LIBRARY (as opposed to the VAX SIG LIBRARY)?
			   If no, explain.

	4. Please list keywords which best describe this program.