Article 128184 of comp.os.vms:
Newsgroups: comp.periphs.scsi,comp.arch.storage,comp.os.vms,vmsnet.misc
Path: nntpd.lkg.dec.com!pa.dec.com!decuac.dec.com!haven.umd.edu!news.umbc.edu!europa.chnt.gtegsc.com!cantaloupe.srv.cs.cmu.edu!das-news2.harvard.edu!oitnews.harvard.edu!rutgers!njitgw.njit.edu!tesla.njit.edu!syshaf
From: syshaf@tesla.njit.edu
Subject: Questions about DAT drives, DDS formats & tapes, and HP drives
Message-ID: <1995Aug29.120238.1@tesla.njit.edu>
Followup-To: comp.periphs.scsi
Keywords: DAT, 4mm, tape, HP, 35480A, C1533A, VMS
Lines: 80
Sender: news@njit.edu
Nntp-Posting-Host: tesla.njit.edu
Organization: 
Date: 29 Aug 95 12:02:38 EDT
Lines: 80
Xref: nntpd.lkg.dec.com comp.periphs.scsi:44035 comp.arch.storage:7514 comp.os.vms:128184 vmsnet.misc:4309

	I am one of several system managers at a university computing center. I 
am trying to get more information about, and some answers to questions about 
4mm DAT tape drives used for backups of various UNIX and VMS systems via SCSI-2 
bus (no PC's - yet 8^) ). We have several drives in-house and have been using
them for backups for about 2 years now. We settled on the 4mm DAT tape format
after using various others, including IBM 3480 cartridges and 8mm tapes, and
now have a library of several hundred 4mm DDS tapes; most are MRS. We backup
many Gigabytes of storage on various systems and are always looking for better
ways and to reduce the amount of time spent on backups. 
	We currently have a DEC TLZ04 (SONY model ?? inside) attached to a DEC 
ULTRIX system, and several OEMed HP35480A drives attached to various UNIX 
systems (SUN and DEC) and DEC VMS systems. Most of the drives see several hours 
of use each night as various file systems are backed up on a rotating basis. 
The HP drives are about 2 years old (see below) and the DEC TLZ04 slightly 
older. The DEC TLZ04 (SONY) is a DDS-1 drive; no compression. The HP35480A is a 
DDS-DC drive; compression configurable. 
	I have several questions about the current and new technologies in 
this area and would be grateful for any info which anyone can supply, but 
please, facts only - not speculation. 

 1. We have seen the least amount of trouble with the DEC TLZ04 drive. To the 
    best of my knowledge, all of the HP35480A drives have had problems at one 
    time or another and have been repaired by our maintenance contractor (the 
    way I understand it, they take the drives back to their shop, remove the 
    drive from the case, and return them to HP for refurbished drives after 
    which they are reassembled and returned to us). HP will not deal with us 
    directly (?), only through the maintenance contractor. Typical problems 
    with the HP drives include: write problems, read problems, tape stuck in 
    mechanism, and various springs etc. expelled from the drive (when this 
    happens, we take drive out of service as it would be playing Russian 
    Roulette to load a tape; almost a sure thing tape will jam in mechanism). 
    Drives usually last between 6-9 months before problems like this develop. 
    Are problems like this typical? What are your experiences? 
 2. Due to carelessness upon our part and our maintenance contractor, the 
    proper configuration switch settings for the various systems were lost. 
    Also, the company from whom we purchased the drives appears to be out of 
    business (hazards of dealing with low bidders) so we can't contact their 
    tech support, who originally configured the drives. We need settings for 3 
    (maybe 4) basic setups: DEC VMS, DEC ULTRIX, SUN (both SUN/OS and SOLARIS 
    if they're different). Yes, I have both the HP35480A product description 
    and the HP DDS configuration guide (note: a manual written by someone who 
    knows what to do for someone who already knows what to do, i.e. very poor 
    descriptions and definitions, unless you are one of the originators of the 
    SCSI standards 8^) ). I also understand, via other info received and 
    practical experience, that the firmware level of the drive makes a 
    difference to DEC VMS. Is this true, what level is needed, and how can I, 
    as a user, determine a particular drive's firmware level? Does this also 
    affect UNIX setups? 
 3. We may need a source of additional/replacement drives. Now that HP has come 
    out with the C1533A DDS-2 drive, are the 35480A drives still in production? 
    Or are distributors left with "just what's in stock"? 
 4. DEC has the TLZ06 drive which is DDS-DC compliant; whose drive is it? (SONY 
    model ?? or HP model ??) Anyone who owns one care to comment? What about 
    the newer TLZ07; I know it is DDS-2 compliant; whose drive? (SONY or HP - 
    model ??) Again, anyone who has one or used one care to comment? 
 5. Can a DDS-2 compliant drive write in DDS-1 or DDS-DC format (I presume it 
    can read them, to be backward compatible)? Can the HP 1533A do it? Is it 
    software configurable, hardware configurable, or both? As I understand it, 
    the compression algorithm for DDS-DC and DDS-2 is the same; true? 
 6. I have seen info to the effect that a 120 meter DAT tape is unusable in a 
    DDS-DC or DDS-1 drive; of course I previously saw that a 90 meter tape was 
    unusable in a DDS-1 drive, which I know to be false. Can the 120m tape be 
    used in a DDS-DC or DDS-1 drive?  
 7. What about a DDS-2 drive writing to a 60m or 90m tape? Does tape have to be 
    blank or degaussed? 
 8. This is probably our biggest concern: For compatability reasons, can a 
    DDS-DC drive read a DDS-2 tape? I understand the compression is the same 
    for both, and know the DDS-2 drive produces narrower tracks/tracks closer 
    together. Will the DDS-DC drive tolerances allow reading the DDS-2 tape? 

I realize this has been rather lengthy, but any info obtained will be greatly 
appreciated. 
-- 
 
Henry Frystak                           New Jersey Institute of Technology
System Administrator                    Computing Services Department
VAX/VMS USENET Newsmanager              University Heights
TESLA::SYSHAF                           Newark, New Jersey   07102
syshaf@tesla.njit.edu                   
 


